Possible Stewart Trade?

[chknwing]

Well its obvious carolina is babying this guys achilles and has probably come to the conclusion that this guys durability, is questionable. They are heavily stacked at RB/FB. Heres a thought,trade stewart for much needed help on the Dline, Deangelo, Goodson, and Beavers can handle the rb spot nicely

[X-Clown]

I'm not sure they would get a whole lot in return if people thought we were giving up on a second year player who was a first round pick. The trade would scream that there's something wrong with his Achilles.

[Vagrant]

Not only would that leave us with nobody else to back up in case of injury, but it would be monumentally stupid to break up one of the best tandems in the NFL simply because you need help at DT.

Williams-Stewart and Smith represent 90% of our offensive effectiveness. We can ill afford to lose any of them.

[Kettle]

this would be a bad time to trade him for reasons X already said. if it is ever done, it needs to wait until his stock is on the rise.

[Gscottnc5]

This thread is dumb

[dpanthersman]

stewart getting traded is as likely and vick coming to the panthers was....

[Rhys]

This thread is dumb

That is an understatement. He said Williams Goodson and Beavers could handle RB. Umm, Beavers isn't even a running back, he's a WR and he's only like 170 pounds, you're crazy. The FO would have to be out of their minds to trade Stewart.

[SCP]

I suggest you watch the Cornhole Song.

[Paul_Menegay]

Well its obvious carolina is babying this guys achilles and has probably come to the conclusion that this guys durability, is questionable. They are heavily stacked at RB/FB. Heres a thought,trade stewart for much needed help on the Dline, Deangelo, Goodson, and Beavers can handle the rb spot nicely

Williams is Williams in part because of Stewart...he needs that big bruiser to soften the defense. Dont get me wrong, williams is a great back, but his numbers might tumble if stewart was to leave.

[Darth Biscuit]

chknwing I hope you didn't join the huddle just for this post... :rolleyes5:

[Paul_Menegay]

I'm not sure they would get a whole lot in return if people thought we were giving up on a second year player who was a first round pick. The trade would scream that there's something wrong with his Achilles.

There IS something wrong with it....achilles are something you have to be- careful with...its either good or its bad...there is no in between when you're talking about that tendon.

[stirs]

I love all the great thinkers.

The thread is not dumb. Unlikely yes, but not dumb. When you want to make a trade, you have to give up something. If a team came to us wanting Diggs for example, what would you ask in return? 6th rounder?

You guys need to quit cutting people as if you were all some sort of football expert. It is a message board.

[Cpanthers5851]

This thread is dumb

:iagree:

[ZedLeppelin]

I would be all for it if we could get a great young DT and then I would sign one of the FA RBs. Think how Portis was traded for Champ Bailey. It's not likely though...