Steve Smith's Panthers Jersey To Be Retired (Unofficial)

[pantherclaw]

You said greatest Panther of all time. That is exactly what I am responding to you. Reading comprehension is your friend.

thank you.

[PantherBoy95]

Just now, pantherclaw said:

You said greatest Panther of all time. That is exactly what I am responding to you. Reading comprehension is your friend.

thank you.

I'm not really sure why you feel the need to come off that way off of a simple question.  Genuinely just wanted to know, as people separate the two.

But hey it says Wise Ass under your Username so I accept you as you come my friend.

[pantherclaw]

Lol. 

Love me some Steve Smith. 

Always have. 

You'd be able to see that looking at my jersey collection.

He is, the greatest receiver in franchise history. 

No where close to being the greatest all time Panther. There are more qualifications for that, that Steve Smith doesn't meet.

[pantherclaw]

Sure is a lot of poo by butt hurt fans.

[Finest-Panthers]

1 hour ago, PantherBoy95 said:

 

Now I'm not sure how valid this source is; besides that he's a player and Steve liked the tweet.

I hope he's correct though for sure. The greatest Panther to have ever stepped on that field in my opinion; definitely top 3.

Steve Smith’s number should never be worn again. And he should have a statue outside BOA in the future. 

[grateflday]

I am all in the boat of Smith being a top 3 and if anything definitely top 5 Panther of all time.  He has been the most dynamic offensive weapon the franchise ever had, and over a long period of time, and stat wise / what he has done, one of the better in the NFL as a whole.  

Even when some compare him to the level of Peppers.  I put Smith above Pep mainly because how many moments and games, especially big time meaningful can you recall Pep dominating and taking over, making a big play vs Smith doing that ??  For me its always Smitty... for Pep I always look back and cant pick a big game where he just beasted out, he was commonly a dud in big games.  I am sure some will post examples where I am wrong , but again.... Smitty was a monster plenty of times and when I look back on both of their careers there are way more times in my mind that Smitty stood out way more than Pep.   

[pantherclaw]

The simple fact that Steve Smith has punched two teammates in the face, disqualifies him as the greatest ever.

Don't shoot the messenger.

[MechaZain]

 

Revised because I pulled up wrong stats:

In order Peppers, Smith, Mills Newton, Kuechly. I expect Cam and Luke to reach top 3 if not top 2 when it’s all said and done.

[KendrickPanther]

Steve is number one. Don't bleeping kid yourselves. Get out of here with Sam Mills. Great player, great person, great coach. Not top 5 greatest Panthers players. 

[pantherclaw]

I'm not the one kidding themselves.

[pantherclaw]

Also shows how little most fans value the same values as the franchise.

[MechaZain]

I don’t hold Steve’s bad antics against his legacy because there were plenty of times when he was the only person in the whole franchise who seemed to give a damn. He was the heart of the team for years and a couple of hotheaded moments don’t erase that.

[panther252]

Not trying to ruffle any feathers, but would he honestly care? I thought he was done with all of us and considers himself a Raven? 

[MechaZain]

15 minutes ago, pantherclaw said:

Also shows how little most fans value the same values as the franchise.

You act like he killed someone he scrapped with a couple of teammates. Jesus. Keep him out of Canton too while you’re at it.