Ranking the top RB's

[CanadianCat]

So without looking at the teams they play on and only skill who would your top 5 backs be?

1 - S Jack - The best RB in the game hands down

2 - MJD

3 - D Will

4 - Turner

5 - Gore

You can probably tell Im not a fan of 'fast' guys like CJ. AP fumbles too much, Rice 'could' be the next Slaton.

Whats your list?

[OneBadassCat]

1. Deangelo Williams

2. Johnathan Stewart

3-32. Everyone else

[Jbro]

CJ had over 2,000 yards in a two back system.

[KillerKat]

Johnson

Williams

Turner

Jackson

Gore

[Crixtala]

Johnson

Williams

Rice

Jackson

MJD

[Sultan33g]

johnson

wiliams

jackson

stewart

mjd

[OneBadassCat]

Honestly I think it gets to a point where there are alot RBs who are at or near the same level it's just which RBs are fortunate enough to have a healthy season or good o-line or a nice passing game. I mean there are a few elite talents but I'm not sure that any of them truly blow the other out of the water except maybe a couple.

[CharlotteBeer.com]

I'll be the first to criticize Peterson for his fumbling problem, but I think his last game is weighing too heavily in the minds of most here.

Adrian Peterson is still a top five back.

[Cpanthers5851]

CJ had over 2,000 yards in a two back system.

eeehhhh, it wasnt so much of a 2 back system this year.

i mean, Lendale had 64 carries.

CJ had 358

[Guild]

Williams, Johnson, MJD, AD

These four are on a different level then all the rest in the league.

I don't know much about SJ other than his team sucks but he is still heralded by some as being great.

[E CaT PanTHer]

Williams, Johnson, MJD, AD

These four are on a different level then all the rest in the league.

I don't know much about SJ other than his team sucks but he is still heralded by some as being great.

who is AD?

[Jbro]

Adrian Peterson, "All Day".

[E CaT PanTHer]

oh ok. But I think the Panthers are the only team in the whole league that actually runs a legit RBBC. The carries are almost split down the middle, and no other team that I can think of does that.

If D-WILL was getting 75% of the carries to J-STEW's 25%, we'd see deangelo put up 2008 esque type numbers every year.

[Cpanthers5851]

haha its funny that there are SSOOOO many people that dont know that Peterson's nickname is AD.

and im not singling anyone out. its just that there are A LOT of people who dont know.