2021 and 2022 drafts

[kungfoodude]

1 hour ago, Basbear said:

I think we had a friendly 2021 bet. I thought it would be in the top five best, but after injuries to christ and repeated ones to horn its lost the juice. Tremble and hubbard are the current best at their spots, allll bet this is the least talented team.....which does fall on the GM. I think rhule was at the wheel for his time and tepper was dead set on adding a QB.  

Even without those two elements, its very hard to defend given the current state. Ive looked over the roster and been meaning to do a thread.......summary- no hope.

 

 

Yeah I was a heavy skeptic of that draft.

[TN05]

Reminder that Scott Fitterer traded away the best RB in the league and a top ten wide receiver in back to back years and we have zero starters out of the trade, but he refused to trade Brian Burns for two firsts and a second and he’s likely to walk next year

[jayboogieman]

50 minutes ago, TN05 said:

Reminder that Scott Fitterer traded away the best RB in the league and a top ten wide receiver in back to back years and we have zero starters out of the trade, but he refused to trade Brian Burns for two firsts and a second and he’s likely to walk next year

Except the starting QB

[kungfoodude]

2 hours ago, kungfoodude said:

Oh I know. The quality over quantity argument missed me entirely. 

Rather the reverse.

I couldn't understand how taking 11 low end picks made any sense.

[raleigh-panther]

On 11/23/2023 at 3:28 PM, PleaseCutStewart said:

In all honesty, a fair amount of the third day picks get cut pretty quickly.

The much more alarming thing is we only have " two hits ", with one of the hits not being able to stay healthy and the other one having an alarmingly bad sophomore slump...

The problem is, even with the picks they chose to make that are still on the team, there were far,  far better choices available 

they invariably chose the wrong player    

…and that is part if several reasons why they are the dumpster fire they are 

[CPantherKing]

Going with my board/picks & Panthers roster since 2021.

(35 DEFENSE) DL: Jalen Carter, Derrick Brown & Osa Odighizuwa. EDGE: Brian Burns & James Houston. LB: Micah Parsons, Shaq Thompson & Jeremy Chinn. S: Markquese Bell. CB: Stephon Gilmore & Coby Bryant.

(West Coast Offense) QB: Brock Purdy. RB: CMC. TE: Jelani Woods WR: Garrett Wilson, DJ Moore & Michael Wilson. OL: Zach Tom, Trey Smith, Jamaree Salyer, Dawand Jones & Taylor Moton.

Note: Other QBs that would have been drafted/signed to compete with Purdy since 2021. Shane Buechele, Desmond Ridder, Aqeel Glass, Jack Coan, Aidan O'Connell & Dorian Thompson-Robinson.

Is this better than the Panthers FO current roster build?

I avoid 1st round QBs unless they meet 5 criteria (very rare). Dual threat freak athletes at the skill position are 1st round priority & if none are available, 1st round is hybrid DT/LB/S who can dominate in the box. Trade down out of the top 20 picks is the 3rd option & go best available TE/EDGE/QB late 1st/early 2nd. All OL are day 3 draft picks for me. CBs are free agents or 3rd to 7th round in the draft.

That's how I want to see a roster built. My 2nd team would be better than the current Panthers roster. This FO is horrible.