Brees is the best QB in the NFL

[itsmeknightsrus10]

If someone can argue this please give it a whirl.

[Dpantherman]

Ill still take Peyton Manning and Tom Brady over him.

[jasonluckydog]

The man is good but I will take Matt Moore.

[Baschski]

Ill still take Peyton Manning and Tom Brady over him.

Yup.

[GoreMetalJunkie]

Brees or Manning would be great. But no to Brady. 3 Superbowls or not... don't like him.

.. he gay :patriot:

[Dpantherman]

Brees or Manning would be great. But no to Brady. 3 Superbowls or not... don't like him.

.. he gay :patriot:

i dont like him either. but i can't take him out of this convo.

[hank pimple butt]

The man is good but I will take Matt Moore.

this!

[SorthNarolina]

If someone can argue this please give it a whirl.

Brady is productive, has records, superbowls, and success so he's in the mix.

Manning is the same.

It's such a debateable issue I don't really feel like disscussing it. Maybe if you say he's the best qb of 09 that would be s solid stance.

[Squirrel]

No it was argued before Jake is better than Brees.

[zebrainz]

Okaaye, umm, he's too short, too nice, has a (bottle) rocket arm, has a WMD growing on the side of his face. It's really nice when someone overcomes the (ahem) shortcomings that life deals them. Bless his heart.

In reality he is the best QB in the NFL today, right up until Sep. 9, 2010. See ya then. Just for perspective, from January to September of 2001 it was Trent Dilfer.

In all seriousness, Brees should be included in the discussion of who is the best right now. I won't argue against him. But you can't come in here, throw down that gauntlet and not expect a raspberry in response.

[Urrymonster]

Bree's is undeniably an elite QB, with an incredibly accurate throw and all the intangibles that make QBs great, I am hesitant to agree because of Sean Payton.

Sean Payton has always been an incredible offensive playcaller and he designs plays and drives with few peers. Considering that you have to wonder if Brees could operate like Manning does, who effectively just has a consultant as an OC. Manning often calls the plays himself.

Brees is incredible, but I think he has the perfect HC who plays to everyone of his strengths. Due to that, it would be hard to put Manning below Brees, simply because of the extra things Manning does over Drew and still performs equally or better in most situations.

In addition Manning has played this way his entire career at this level, Brees has not, which does suggest that and Sean Payton have got the best out of each other.

[Cavscout]

Active QB's:

1-Brady

2-Manning

3-Brees

4-Favre

All-Time QB's: Brees would not scratch the top ten

[mountainpantherfan]

Just because the Saints won the Super Bowl? That makes them the better team but says nothing about individual players. Brees is a very good QB and among the elite today but not the best. That doesn't mean he can't become the best and very well could but he just isn't there yet.

In all honesty, it's hard to say this when Brady has 3 rings and Big Ben has 2. And while I really don't like Ben or the Steelers, Ben would have never got thrown around like Brees did by Freeny on that one play in the SB.

[csx]

If someone can argue this please give it a whirl.

You just won the Super Bowl, why the fug do you feel the need to be justfied by another teams fans?