Who's better, Kolb or Moore?

[Dpantherman]

will analysts like Jamie Dukes say "who is that guy"? when discussing the QB situation in philly? or will he automatically do well bc hes had 2 starts with 300 passing yards? personally, I can't wait to hear what they have to say just to compare stories. or is it worth comparing? what do you think?

[Delhommey]

Fk the analyst. Let's see it on the field.

I do think Kolb is a more talented QB as of now.

[Awesomeness!!]

I've only seen one game from Kolb and he looked good, but he has started before and looked sub par (didnt catch those games) so I'll go with Moore since I know what to expect

[Swarly]

Everyone recognizes him, and labels him better because he was a 2nd round draft pick. He has done absolutely nothing that would put him ahead of Moore, but since Moore went undrafted, he's automatically better.(in the eyes of the media/etc.)

[jbland]

Ill hold opinion until after the season.

[Brokenbad]

will analysts like Jamie Dukes say "who is that guy"? when discussing the QB situation in philly? or will he automatically do well bc hes had 2 starts with 300 passing yards? personally, I can't wait to hear what they have to say just to compare stories. or is it worth comparing? what do you think?

Saw an article on NFL.com stating how Kolb "Light up Kansas City" (what an unbelieveable task BTW) but I seriously doubt anything about how much ass Moore has kicked against some really good teams with alot to play for will ever be mentioned.....

[theyhateme45]

Ill hold opinion until after the season.

This.... I'll wait and let their play on the field do the talking this year.

[Brokenbad]

http://www.nfl.com/news/story?id=09000d5d81748687&template=with-video-with-comments&confirm=true

Heres the link to "Kolb lights up Kansas City"

[DaveThePanther2008]

We are somewhat responsible for Kolb's rise to power. We hurt McNabb during our 1st game. I cannot remember if McNabb played the next week or not but I do know he eventually took a couple of weeks off after he got hurt against us. Which gave Kolb his starts and Philly's belief he could be good.

Kolb had 2 - 300 yd games during those few starts. Impressive, most definitely but enough to want him over Moore. I am not sold. Moore (as stated before) has excelled against some pretty decent competition.

Moore is better suited for us. He is solid enough to keep a defense honest. Has faith in our OLine to protect him so he isn't rattled by pressure when required to throw. Has the arm to get it down field. He is a good game manager and IMO what this team needs. We don't need a 300+ yd QB. That isn't our forte.

Go Panthers

[Snake]

Moore dose not have the arm Kolb dose but his decision making and vision is a whole lot better. Moore was putting some Brady like performances on at the end of the season.

[DaveThePanther2008]

Moore dose not have the arm Kolb dose but his decision making and vision is a whole lot better. Moore was putting some Brady like performances on at the end of the season.

Philly Offense is a WCO short dump off passes with an occassional downfield throw. Moore seems to have ever tool Kolb has.

[c0r]

kolb.

and i am an eagle fan who has never liked him since they drafted him.

[Swarly]

kolb.

and i am an eagle fan who has never liked him since they drafted him.

explain how he's better

Moore in his first starts this year(5 games): 4-1, 8TD/1INT, 1,053 yards, 98.5 QB rating, 61.1% completions.

Kolb in his first starts this year(2 games): 1-1, 4TD/3INT, 741 yards, 88.9 QB rating, 64.6% completions.

[c0r]

i think kolb has more upside/potential. he was a second round pick for a reason. mcnabb got ripped for not 'being accurate' and kolb will def have a better completion percentage than mcnabb did most years. he played in a short pass offense in college which we know the eagles love to throw the ball so i do believe he is better suited for this offense than other QBs.

that said, i hated when they picked him in the second round, hoped he failed when he got a chance to play and would still take him over matt moore.