So where would you put Steve Smith on your top ten list of receivers?

[Smithers]

I think Colsten, Santonio Holmes, Greg Jennings, and DeSean Jackson deserve a mention as top 10 current players, in addition to some of those mentioned above. I don't think Roddy White should make the cut, and Ochocinco's numbers have been average at best the past 2 seasons.

[Smithers]

1. Andre Johnson

2. Fitz (It will be interesting to see how he does without Kurt)

3. Smitty

4. Wes Welker

5. Miles Austin

6. Vincent Jackson

7. Reggie Wayne

8. Desean Jackson

9. Randy Moss

10. Sidney Rice

I like this list...I would swap Welker and Jackson though.

[venom]

1. Jerry Rice

2. Steve Smith

3. Larry Fitzgerald

4. Randy Moss

only because to me smith reinvented the position and made it as tough as ever, in his case. with the exception of fitzgerald, the others to me are like gazelle's, which can tend to be boring

[Ricky Spanish]

you guys aren't giving ochocinco enough credit guys. look at his stats...

from 2001-2009, had 7 seasons of over 1,000 receiving yards, the two he didn't were when he was injured and his rookie year, 4 of those 1k years were over 1,300 receiving

averages 7 TDs per year, subtract his rookie season, he averages 8.

total career averages:

76 Receptions per year

7 TDs per year

1,105 yards per year

that's damn good people.

[necroplasm]

Andre Johnson, Larry Fitzgerald and Steve Smith are the top 3 in the game these days.

[Wither]

Currently? Somewhere in the top 10-15.

All-time? Hard to say... but he will be remembered, if that makes any difference (and not just by Panther fans).

[Johnny Rockets]

Currently? Somewhere in the top 10-15.

All-time? Hard to say... but he will be remembered, if that makes any difference (and not just by Panther fans).

I think this is realistic....I would probably say he is within the top 10.

I bet if this was done on a national level, he wouldn't be in the top 10 and probably finish behind the NYG Steve Smith.

[CatMan72]

Listen guys, I'm a die-hard Panthers fan and a huge Smitty fan... but if we're talking about top 10 all time, my list wouldn't include Smitty.

[CatMan72]

But I do think Smitty is one of the top "pound-for-pound" WR's of all time.

[CatMan72]

I think this is realistic....I would probably say he is within the top 10.

I bet if this was done on a national level, he wouldn't be in the top 10 and probably finish behind the NYG Steve Smith.

NYG Steve Smith hasn't done enough yet to deserve to be mentioned in the same sentence as our Steve Smith.

[CatMan72]

Smitty is in my current top 10, but not all time top 10.

[thefuzz]

Do you base this on production, or who you would want on your team today?

Who do I want on my team....

Johnson A.

Johnson C.

Fitz

Jackson

Smith

Wayne...could be skewed

after that is get murky

[Wither]

I think this is realistic....I would probably say he is within the top 10.

I bet if this was done on a national level, he wouldn't be in the top 10 and probably finish behind the NYG Steve Smith.

I mean, I'm obviously a Smith fan (avatar, signature) and with bias I'd say he's top 5 but I was being conservative with the top 10-15.

[Ricky Spanish]

But I do think Smitty is one of the top "pound-for-pound" WR's of all time.

no doubt. Pound for pound, he's one of the best ever, imagine the poo he could do if he were brandon marshall's size? he'd probably kill people when he punched them...