Clausen vs Smith

[Jpjr]

Forget about who would win in a fight. (SS every time)

The question is who would win on the field. All I'll say is that a lot of people thought Golden Tate was the better half of the Jimmy/Golden connection last year.

But when people asked Golden if he was staying in college for his senior year (and a Heismen run), he said there was no decision. He was coming back if Clausen came back, going to the NFL if he wasn't.

I hope that Clausen and Steve Smith can start hooking up in the same way. Become symbiotic to the point where neither one wants to play without the other. That is probably the single biggest reason to be excited about the future. But it will take some time... Golden Tate was not Jimmy Clausen's leading receiver during their freshman year.

[Catdaddy]

Who ya got?

After all the talk during the week about Smith getting in Jimmy's face on the sidelines last Sunday, I thought it'd be interesting to get people's opinions on who'd actually win in that fight.

Personally, my money is on Clausen. He's a tough bastard.

Yep, you are right. Smitty is a tough little thing, but if Clausen connects, lights out. A QB would knock anyone out cold if he got a good shot!

[PantherFan52]

Yep, you are right. Smitty is a tough little thing, but if Clausen connects, lights out. A QB would knock anyone out cold if he got a good shot!

LIES!!!Mark Sanchez would get his poo ran by 80% of WR's in the league lol

[Primetime 89]

ask ken lucas who would win

[KatsAzz]

Steve Smith is my favorite all-time Panthers player but his immaturity was shown when he went off on Jimmy Clausen,a rookie QB starting his first NFL game.

That is no way for a team captain to act and sets a poor example for himself to and the rest of the team.

I will continue to support Smitty but his uncalled for outspoken acts toward teammates,falsely called being competive,is total BS,in my opinion and need to stop.

[Pox 08]

in a fist fight, smith would whoop jimmy.

but, i kinda wish that jimmy woulda stood up for himself, and got in smitty's face on the sidelines.

this is his team now, and he had a perfect oppertunity to show the other guys that he had balls and self-respect, but he didnt do it.

a leader woulda put smith in his place, and told him to keep his mouth shut, until he gets open.

It would be something interesting to see, that's for sure. I would hate losing two players though. Clausen with a facial injury and Smith with a suspension. I know we joke about it, but I can seriously see Smith beating the hell out of Clausen if Clausen actually got in his face right back. :yesnod:

[PanthersPhan18]

Who would win in a fight would've been my last guess about what this thread is about.

[Ricky Spanish]

you serious? smith hands down no questions asked.

now a real fight would be between beason and smitty. who would win THAT one?

[OneBadassCat]

you serious? smith hands down no questions asked.

now a real fight would be between beason and smitty. who would win THAT one?

I think Beason would take him. He's 240 lbs of pure muscle.

[Lumps]

shouldn't be v.s they are on the same team

[TheRealDeal]

Can't believe anyone would believe the silver spoon fed Clausen would even get a punch off before Smitty has him taking a dirt nap

[KatsAzz]

I think Beason would take him. He's 240 lbs of pure muscle.

Exactly...No way Smitty could take Beason,unless he sucker punched him.