What about Peppers to DC for Colt Brennan and a 1st (or more)?

[top dawg]

What do you guys think about Colt Brennan? Would he and the Skins' first round pick be enough for Pep? I was just playing around with different scenarios. Someone had posted early on in the season that Pep might want to go to Washington.

I know that Brennan broke all kinds of records at Hawaii, but some questiones his effectiveness as an NFL QB. Here are some interesting links regarding Brennan and Pep to DC:

June Jones/Dan Patrick discussing Brennan

Colt Brennan Homer

Pep probably won't end up in DC

[KillerKat]

I like Brennan. Was outstanding in college and performed good during the preseason for the 'Skins.

[davos]

Hmm...another possibility. I don't hate the guy but you are reaching here. For Peppers, I think we need to get a player that is already quality.

[Mr. Scot]

While we're at it, let's sign Timmy Chang

Julius Peppers for Colt Brennan? Even with the first thrown in, that's one of the most one-sided trades in history, and we would be on the wrong end. That'd make it twice the Redskins screwed us in a franchise player trade.

(geez, and I thought the "Peppers for Anderson" threads were bad)

[top dawg]

Hmm...another possibility. I don't hate the guy but you are reaching here. For Peppers, I think we need to get a player that is already quality.

Brennan would just be a little more sugar to sweeten the deal. According to the football pundits, we may find it difficult to get equal value for Pep.

[top dawg]

While we're at it, let's sign Timmy Chang

(and I thought the "Peppers for Anderson" threads were bad)

Come on, Scottie. You're supposed to be the "voice of reason."

[top dawg]

This is not a straight deal, Pep for Brennan. If you noticed, I asked about Brennan, a first rounder, and possibly more. Geez.

[VA Panther Fan]

Living in Skins country, I can tell you that Brennan will never be more than a 2nd or 3rd string QB. He's very slight, throws with a wierd arm angle and is not getting a lot of positive press by anyone with a strong football background.

[Mr. Scot]

Come on, Scottie. You're supposed to be the "voice of reason."

Sorry man, but that's an awful trade. You don't trade a franchise level player for a backup QB that "might" be a good pro.

If you want a player, it's got to be one that's at least close to equal value. Brennan is all potential at this point, and he played in a system that made Timmy Chang look like a world beater too.

I understand that people want something in trade, but that's not gonna do it.

[Panthro]

Sorry man, but that's an awful trade. You don't trade a franchise level player for a backup QB that "might" be a good pro.

If you want a player, it's got to be one that's at least close to equal value. Brennan is all potential at this point, and he played in a system that made Timmy Chang look like a world beater too.

I understand that people want something in trade, but that's not gonna do it.

Um thats why he said Brennan and a 1st rd pick

[L.A. Fanatic]

besides the fact that trade sucks. no rapist QBs please

Sanchez or Brennan

[Mr. Scot]

Um thats why he said Brennan and a 1st rd pick

See above. I said even with the pick thrown in there's no way I'd take that trade.

Personally, I think Brennan is a bust waiting to happen. Regardless of opinion though, trading a player like Peppers for a guy like Brennan (even with the 1st rounder) is an awful idea.

[top dawg]

But Scottie, some say that we'd be lucky to get a first round pick at all, much less one with a player with some potential (however limited).

[Mr. Scot]

But Scottie, some say that we'd be lucky to get a first round pick at all, much less one with a player with some potential (however limited).

I don't agree with the notion that we can't get at least a 1st and 3rd for him.

There's just no way I could be convinced that swapping Peppers for a pick and a guy whose only claim to fame is as a "preseason star" and college record setter. You might as well trade for Tim Couch.