If you knew Newton would hit his upside

[Cyberjag]

would you prefer him over Luck?

[JawnyBlaze]

Yes. That's a big IF though. Luck's IF isn't as big. It's cuz he's white.

[ammofan]

What is his upside tho? Because Luck has the upside that could make him the best QB in the league...

[micnificent28]

If both lived up to there maximum potential newton would surpass luck. That said newtons floor is far lower than lucks.

[Delhommey]

Jawny, that's your warning.

[Rhys]

Physically, Newton is far more talented than Luck. If he reaches his potential, then he could be that game changer people oft refer to, something like what he did in college.

SO yes, I would prefer him over Luck, especially since Luck scorned us to finish his architecture degree. A degree I can assure you is highly useless unless you're extremely talented at it. NCSU has a highly lauded design school that offers architecture and I know many graduates of the program that cannot find a job and work in coffee shops and such.

Damn you LUCK. Bad Luck, bad.

Plus you didn't ask if people preferred a Newton who has reached his potential over a Luck who has reached his potential, so it would be a bigger risk at that point.

Boomshakalaka, I just logicKED yo asses.

[Cyberjag]

If both lived up to there maximum potential newton would surpass luck. That said newtons floor is far lower than lucks.

This is kind of what I'm wondering. Do you guys in general feel like Newton's upside is higher than Luck's?

[Delhommey]

If you maxed out both players, you'd have an interesting choice but that's kinda like a Batman vs Spiderman type argument.

In that situation though I'd take Cam because I know we can since we have the first pick the year he's coming out.

[Icege]

If you maxed out both players, you'd have an interesting choice but that's kinda like a Batman vs Spiderman type argument.

In that situation though I'd take Cam because I know we can since we have the first pick the year he's coming out.

Prep-time Batman is one of the most difficult heroes to beat.

[teeray]

Interesting question. I know people like to think I am a blind huggernfor cam but if Luck would have come out I would have been hugging him even more.

But if both maximized their potential I woulf prob go Cam becaue of his running ability. But like someone else said it would be like picking batman or superman

[caddieman]

With Newton coming to town this week I wonder if the Panthers staff have locked away their computers?;)

[JawnyBlaze]

What, it was a penis joke. I didn't think it was outta line. I've seen far worse get through here... Sorry if it was...

Jawny, that's your warning.

[Rhys]

With Newton coming to town this week I wonder if the Panthers staff have locked away their computers?;)

Eh, I wouldn't worry, since he didn't steal the computer at Florida, he bought it from someone who had stolen it.

So unless they already have a thief amongst them who would be offering Cam great deals on laptops that he couldn't pass up, I think it'll be OK.

[Millions]

Can't lose with either one honestly feel like both have the potential to be one of the best young QB's in the NFL along with guys like Bradford, Freeman, Ryan etc.

Luck could be a more mobile Manning and Cam can't really be compared to anyone he's a freak of nature like a mix of a few QB's with his size, arm strength and athletic ability win/win. Would lie if I said It would be easy to pick one or the other.