PFW Previews Panther Prospects

[Udogg]

I can very well see Gabbert playing well. Maybe not Aaron Rodgers level but well. But all the clips and the 2 games I saw, he didn't look good. Especially with pressure. I don't think that's teachable tbh. It seems like some QB's handle pressure some don't. I also don't think Gabbert is extremely accurate in games. However he threw pretty well on the move. I don't think he gets a lot of credit for that. As far a limited on field ability in the passing game, not being able to make the big throws is as big a limitation as well. I don't think we should draft on how likely a player is to be hurt. I mean look at Carlson Palmer and Tom Brady's injuries. I think Cam is the better athlete and has the better arm. Going off stats he is probably more accurate in game situations. I think right now today, Cam is better than Gabbert. No one knows whats going to happen 5-7 down the road. Hell Cam might get hit by a bus the day after the draft. Same with Gabbert.

[panthers55]

Yeah there is biased and there is a hatchet job.

will always test the rules. By all accounts he follows order and does what he is told. One TD in a game instead of a kneel down is hardly always

need to avoid trapping of fame. Why isn't that an issue with everyone else then. No one put it in anyone else's review but Newton

stained heisman trophy No evidence at all

littered recruiting path No evidence at all. What about Peterson???

can provide intial spark but will be quickly dissected by NFL defenses ? How will that be different from Gabbert? Does his say this??

overhyped? As you say overcriticized would apply.

tainting locker room? All reports is he is great in the locker room

foreclose on gm's future? Just as many people think he will be a homerun in a few years as a bust. I also suspect Richardson and Morrison will be heavy involved so I doubt this all hangs on Hurney

Fixed it for you.

[teeray]

I guess I can't figure out why if Narwocki did such in depth research on these guys how come he didn't unearth the underage drinking incident by Gabbert that took a Huddler all of a Google search to find?? Was he too busy looking for Cam's negatives??

[teeray]

Although I do have to say that Gabberts thing is silly. But after Kerry Collins......

[Jackofalltrades]

Peterson's pay for play is alledged, Cam's is proven- oh that's right, ignorance is a defense because he didn't know.

Cam earned that criticism, all the way. Character is his biggest issue, get over it.

[Jackofalltrades]

I guess I can't figure out why if Narwocki did such in depth research on these guys how come he didn't unearth the underage drinking incident by Gabbert that took a Huddler all of a Google search to find?? Was he too busy looking for Cam's negatives??

Maybe it's viewed as one, isolated and insignificant incident?

No one has brought it up, not just Nawrocki. If anyone thought it was if any significance I would have been reveled before now.

[panthers55]

Peterson's pay for play is alledged, Cam's is proven- oh that's right, ignorance is a defense because he didn't know.

Cam earned that criticism, all the way. Character is his biggest issue, get over it.

Newton's is alleged but there is nothing to link him to it.

Peterson's is alleged as well. No proof of either. You are innocent until proven guilty. Stop slandering without any basis.

[teeray]

Peterson's pay for play is alledged, Cam's is proven- oh that's right, ignorance is a defense because he didn't know.

Cam earned that criticism, all the way. Character is his biggest issue, get over it.

Didn't Dareus miss some time because of dealing with an agent?? That was proven. To a larger extent than even Newton who was cleared (so far).

[panthers55]

Didn't Dareus miss some time because of dealing with an agent?? That was proven. To a larger extent than even Newton who was cleared (so far).

Or what about Bryant's $600,000 of jewelry to bought as an undergraduate as a loan from an agent. Wonder how PFW missed all that as well last year.

[mountainpantherfan]

I don't see the Newton review as being unfair. I'm not saying I agree with it but I think it is a fair review and opinion. And as readers we can decide to take from it whatever we want.

I do however have a problem when you read the review of Fairly and then read the reviews of the remaining players. I wouldn't go as far as to say there is racsial elements to his reviews but biased agaisnt a school, I could see that.

Like I said, on it's own the Newton review isn't so bad in my opinion but there isn't a consistantcy in the other reviews of players that attend schools other than Aubrun.

Just my .02

[teeray]

I don't see the Newton review as being unfair. I'm not saying I agree with it but I think it is a fair review and opinion. And as readers we can decide to take from it whatever we want.

I do however have a problem when you read the review of Fairly and then read the reviews of the remaining players. I wouldn't go as far as to say there is racsial elements to his reviews but biased agaisnt a school, I could see that.

Like I said, on it's own the Newton review isn't so bad in my opinion but there isn't a consistantcy in the other reviews of players that attend schools other than Aubrun.

Just my .02

Someone claimed Narwocki was and Alabama grad. I haven't been able to confirm that. Does Scot or anyone else know??

[Mr. Scot]

Where is the concern about Peterson being pretty stupid and taking money to sign. I guess he has no issues worth noting.

Check the date of the article vs the date the Peterson story broke.

[panthers55]

Check the date of the article vs the date the Peterson story broke.

So we can agree that they publish what they have but don't update it if additional info is available. Kind of makes it obsolete pretty quickly.

[Mr. Scot]

I guess I can't figure out why if Narwocki did such in depth research on these guys how come he didn't unearth the underage drinking incident by Gabbert that took a Huddler all of a Google search to find?? Was he too busy looking for Cam's negatives??

Know how I know you didn't read the profile? :D

Was involved in a fight outside a Columbia pizza parlor in February 2010 that left his brother, Tyler, with a broken nose, although no arrests were made.

The story from the TV station said the police believed the players may have been drinking but didn't actually test them. So as a matter of record, it's only listed as a fight.

Someone claimed Narwocki was and Alabama grad. I haven't been able to confirm that. Does Scot or anyone else know??

Nawrocki played linebacker at Illinois.

I can tell you from reading his reviews of Alabama players (Dareus included) that the "school bias" thing has no legs.