If the Colts get the #1 pick?

[Jangler]

Would they really trade Manning? Luck might be the next coming of Cam :cam: but really, do you trade away a proven QB even at 85% for an unknown QB?

[Darth Biscuit]

Why wouldn't they keep Manning for at least one more year to have him mentor Luck then trade him the next offseason?

I would bet that they will get more for Manning after a year back playing than they will now with him coming off season ending surgery.

[Jangler]

They keep comparing this to Montana/Young. Young was not a rookie, still don't understand that one...

Why would Manning not want to mentor Luck? He's not Pharve...

[Kevin Greene]

Who is going to trade for a 20mil per year QB with a bad neck?

[X-Clown]

Who is going to trade for a 20mil per year QB with a bad neck?

Never say never about the Raiders. (or the Redskins)

[Davidson Deac II]

Who is going to trade for a 20mil per year QB with a bad neck?

When he is one of the alltime greats and still has a couple of years or perhaps more left? I bet a lot of teams would. Teams with the number one pick take a far bigger risk picking an unproven rookie out of college and paying him a lot of money.

Of course, he would have to pass a physical first though.

My guess is the Colts take Luck if they can, and if Manning comes back able to play, Luck sits for a year or two.

[adub2b23]

My guess is luck won't want to sit. I feel like if he's #1 to the colts manning will be gone. They need to rebuild and trading manning for picks is a start

[Henne Given Sunday]

Reports are that Manning "won't let them draft Luck"

If they do, he will demand a release or trade. So who knows....

[Jangler]

Dolphins would jump all over Manning, wouldn't they?

[The Saltman]

Reports are that Manning "won't let them draft Luck"

If they do, he will demand a release or trade. So who knows....

its ok miami is getting luck anyway

[Inimicus]

When he is one of the alltime greats and still has a couple of years or perhaps more left? I bet a lot of teams would. Teams with the number one pick take a far bigger risk picking an unproven rookie out of college and paying him a lot of money.

Of course, he would have to pass a physical first though.

My guess is the Colts take Luck if they can, and if Manning comes back able to play, Luck sits for a year or two.

The caveat to that is that Peyton looks super human in an offense where he controls the play from the LOS. He adjusts run/pass, routes, hot reads, all from the line. I'm thinking he will look considerably more human in an offense that's not built around him in the same way.

[Gazi]

You have to trade Manning. Get few more picks in that draft to build up that defense. Rich get richer.

[Davidson Deac II]

You have to trade Manning. Get few more picks in that draft to build up that defense. Rich get richer.

Only after you find out for certain that Luck can play at the NFL level.

[Hawk]

I would get Paul Allan to give up all his stocks in Microsoft to get Manning for even just a season or two