2008-2010 Drafts Evaluated By Pff

[CRA]

http://www.profootballfocus.com/blog/2012/04/09/draft-grader-carolina-panthers/

Always an interesting read....

The misses and bad picks are

Godfrey

Martin

Irvin

Robinson

Clausen

Brown

Edwards

[OnlyPantherFaninMaine]

I wouldn't consider Godfrey a "miss" or "bad" pick, for a 3rd round pick he has performed about how I expected he would although I am hoping the safety signings this off-season light a fire under his ass.

[LinvilleGorge]

Yeah, I wouldn't consider him a miss or a bad pick for a 3rd rounder, but that contract we signed him too was a miss.

[koolkatluke]

http://www.profootba...olina-panthers/

Always an interesting read....

The misses and bad picks are

Godfrey

Martin

Irvin

Robinson

Clausen

Brown

Edwards

PFF sometimes is full of poo. Clausen was put in a crazy situation and in the 2nd round with Moore the only QB on the roster I would have made that pick. I wouldn't call that a bad Pick yet.

Martin and Godfrey while not being great have made plays and played better when the front 7 was better.

[Sean Payton's Vicodin]

fuging duke robinson... he was the best guard in CFB one year and fuged up everything after. i had high hope for him <_<

i also wish we would have kept pike instead of clausen

[CRA]

PFF sometimes is full of poo. Clausen was put in a crazy situation and in the 2nd round with Moore the only QB on the roster I would have made that pick. I wouldn't call that a bad Pick yet.

Martin and Godfrey while not being great have made plays and played better when the front 7 was better.

Well, in the comments the defend Clausen to a degree and acknowledge his bad situation...

[Jackofalltrades]

fuging duke robinson... he was the best guard in CFB one year and fuged up everything after. i had high hope for him <_<

i also wish we would have kept pike instead of clausen

Robinson was never the best guard in CFB. He was good, but certainly not best and his extreme lack of work ethic got him flushed.

[Seal (SmittyIsOurSavior)]

David Gettis, WR

(198th overall pick in 2010): Gettis missed his second season after a horrid first year. The Panthers asked too much from him as a rookie sixth rounder.

Horrid first year? Yeah, f*ck whoever made this.