If you could only keep..

[Brandon]

Gross- good left tackles are rare, great left tackles are worth their weight in diamonds

Kalil- look at all the truly great offensive lines and they all had top notch centers

D. Williams- ran for 10 yards or more an average one out of every four plays

Beason- Exceptional leader and athlete, the total package

Smith- A truly dangerous offensive weapon, and versatile enough to work in any system

[Fiz]

gross

wharton

kalil

otah

beason

[iTzSMITH89 4TDx89]

i think people are leaving him out because Stewart has proven he can be a starter in the nfl and the panthers need Smith, Gross and Beason more then we need D.will

[Brandon]

gross

wharton

kalil

otah

beason

This was the first iteration of my list, but decided against it because it was a bit too OL heavy.

[top dawg]

D. Will

Beason

Pep

Smith

Otah

[mantal]

I'll just keep all of them. I've never been good with authority, real or assumed...

But I can't believe the votes for Stewart over DeAngelo. I mean I love the guy, but as of yet, he hasn't taken place in preseason workouts in his first two years due to injury...

[thefuzz]

The three that we could not afford to lose would be

Smith

Gross

Beason

add two more to that and you have

Peppers

Gamble

[Lt Pinkerton]

This is going to be controversial, but here is my list:

Deangelo Williams

Jonathan Beason

Jordan Gross

Steve Smith

Julius Peppers

[nosuchthingasapanther]

But I can't believe the votes for Stewart over DeAngelo. I mean I love the guy, but as of yet, he hasn't taken place in preseason workouts in his first two years due to injury...

...and yet look at what he's been able to do.

[mantal]

I'll just keep all of them. I've never been good with authority, real or assumed...

But I can't believe the votes for Stewart over DeAngelo. I mean I love the guy, but as of yet, he hasn't taken place in preseason workouts in his first two years due to injury...

...and yet look at what he's been able to do.

Let the record stand...

[AKPantherFan]

Smith

Williams

Otah

Beason

Gross

[Panther Boyd]

Beason

D. Will

Smitty

Gross

Delhomme......that's right I'd keep jake!!!!!!