Would you trade Cam Newton for Cleveland's 2 Number 1 picks?

[Sean Payton's Vicodin]

sure, why the fug not, he's been all but ruined by shula and co

[CharlottePanther]

We would possibly have 3 top 12 picks. Bridgewater, Sammy Watkins and Bradley Roby in the 1st then draft O line the rest of the draft

[BIGH2001]

Well maybe because he evaluated nfl players for a living and was considered very successful at doing so. Anyway it a not like he's the only credible person out there who thinks the same.

And I care what Polian thinks becauseeee?

Gee, I wonder why Cam doesn't have a winning record yet.

[CelibatePimp]

Which of you mods had this great idea and decided to start the thread? Cos no one can start a thread with 1 post. He did not even get back to reply to anyone on the thread.

 

Which of the mods started this troll job? Confess!!!

[BIGH2001]

He also had those 4 straight Super Bowls in buffalo and the panthers went to the NFC title game in their second year as a franchise. Just sayin'

Sorry but Polian is only viewed as successful because he drafted Peyton Manning. Yeah, he certainly spotted the diamond in the rough there. He said RG3 and Kaepernick were superior pocket passers. Yeah? Sounds like his prediction has been way off course considering Cam is making the throws Kaep and RG3 can't make in the pocket. Great talent evaluator, my ass. Where's he now? On ESPN along with Gruden, Jaws, Mangini, etc.

Take your Polian love with you and GTFO. Nobody is buying what you're selling.

[Squirrel]

Honestly, if I'm DG, yes, you make that trade.

 

You would likely have two top 10's and a 25-28 or so pick.

 

If you are bringing in a new HC and full coaching staff, that is a lot to work with after blowing this roster up.

 

That said, will never, ever happen.

 

 

That would make it very tempting. 

[Wanderlai]

If everyone thinks your no good....maybe, just maybe, instead of saying the world is wrong it could be that they are correct. I'm not saying Cam is no good but I'm a Panthers fan so my opinion is biased.

[TheRed]

If everyone thinks your no good....maybe, just maybe, instead of saying the world is wrong it could be that they are correct. I'm not saying Cam is no good but I'm a Panthers fan so my opinion is biased.

Define "everyone". A couple mouth breathers on the Carolina Huddle don't count either.

[SZ James (banned)]

Hell yes I would

[VIP]

yes, no brainer

[Wanderlai]

Define "everyone". A couple mouth breathers on the Carolina Huddle don't count either.

 

Jesus Christ guy, do you watch or read anything in the sports world related to Cam. No one is singing his praises. Most analysts and sports writers think he is way below all the other young QBs starting in the league. While I don't agree with the bulk of what's said I do see his flaws. Its idiotic to ignore 90% of "experts" who see him as not that good. I'm biased as I'm looking every game for a silver lining and giving him the benefit of the doubt. I'm not a Cam hater or nut hugger. Bottom line is he is not leading this team to being better since he has been here. He is the face of the franchise so he is the guy that takes most of the heat...warranted or not.

[TheRed]

Jesus Christ guy, do you watch or read anything in the sports world related to Cam. No one is singing his praises. Most analysts and sports writers think he is way below all the other young QBs starting in the league. While I don't agree with the bulk of what's said I do see his flaws. Its idiotic to ignore 90% of "experts" who see him as not that good. I'm biased as I'm looking every game for a silver lining and giving him the benefit of the doubt. I'm not a Cam hater or nut hugger. Bottom line is he is not leading this team to being better since he has been here. He is the face of the franchise so he is the guy that takes most of the heat...warranted or not.

Lmao who are these "experts" you are referring to? The hacks at ESPN that barely know more than a few of our players names? Pffft...

[Squirrel]

Looking at the draft there is only 2 viable QB's to replace Cam if we did the trade.  Bridgewater and Boyd.  Johnny Football isn't better than Cam.  Not saying Boyd and Bridgewater is better but closer Cam.  So if we did do the trade we would need to spend 1 pick on them if they are available.  We would have 2 picks left in the first.  1 would defiantly be for a OT maybe even both on OT.  With this trade we could almost shore up our OLine for years to come and possibly get a Qb that is as good as Cam.  This would be a great trade for us for the future of the team.

 

The risk are there too.  Either Bridgewater or Boyd are not there when we first draft.  Or they are both big bust. But still would do the trade if offered.

[pstall]

If objectivity was a requirement to be a sports fan. there proly wouldn't be any sports fans.