Jay Roosevelt

You're right. Let's just fold the franchise.

Who...?

Hurney was solid during his first run; his bigger issues were generally the contracts he was giving out. The middle rounds were a weak point for him, but he still did draft guys like Ryan Kalil, Charles Johnson, Travelle Wharton, Josh Norman, Greg Hardy (off-field issues aside, the guy could play), Ricky Manning, and Geoff Hangartner. Not all Pro Bowlers or anything, but some were and others were solid players for us. Gettleman was, IMO, the worst for the simple fact that he seemed to have ZERO instincts on how to actually construct and/or maintain a winning roster. Yes, we did have more success under his tenure as G.M. but we did it largely with players drafted by Marty Hurney. Gettleman did have some early success with Star, K.K. Short, Trai Turner, and finding Andrew Norwell as a UDFA, but also drafted two of our bigger 1st round busts in Kelvin Benjamin and Vernon Butler. His entire approach to team building was schizophrenic at best; he went from signing exclusively bargain bin free agents in 2013-2015 to handing out a massive deal to Matt Kalil and this was after completely botching the Josh Norman situation in 2016. His tenure as the Giants G.M. saw more of this type of team-building and their lack of success during that time I think shows what we would have dealt with had he not inherited a very talented roster from Marty Hurney. Scott Fitterer... well, it's too soon to say. Certainly the results haven't been great in terms of our record, but we really don't know how many of the mistakes of the past few years were his decisions and how many were Matt Rhule's. I do like his approach to filling holes on the roster better than Gettleman's (full bargain bin) or Hurney (big spending on mid-tier players). Long-term I think his legacy will be all about how successful Bryce Young is and how good a team he can assemble around him long-term. Obviously it's not looking real promising at the moment, but it is important to note that it IS still early and that this is really only his second year without Rhule having full roster control.

This graph tells me they're trying to do too much with what we have. Just because Bryce can run the full offense doesn't mean we have the personnel to run it successfully.

Jeremy Chinn is terrible in coverage. He's the most overrated player on the roster. I, for one, would not consider extending him. He's been living off his draft status and name recognition for 2 years now.

You're clearly missing Frank's grand and insidious plan to secretly bench Brady Christensen so he can ride Calvin Throckmorton to the Super Bowl and get a lifetime contract from David Tepper.

You think Reich's plan is to ride Andy Dalton to the promised land? Come on. If this was his plan he wouldn't have named Bryce the starter before training camp and let the competition play out. Tepper isn't going to want his #1 pick who we traded a ton for riding the bench so Reich can take us to the playoffs at 8-9 and get blown out in the wild card round. That's not going to save his job. Tepper didn't pay this "all-star" coaching staff to not be able to develop our #1 overall pick QB. If Reich benches Bryce Young, he's admitting that he either a) made a huge mistake drafting him, and/or b) is unable to develop him. Which is EXACTLY what he was brought in to do! Regardless of what you think of Bryce (it's pretty clear you've never been a fan of the pick; probably a Levis guy) the notion that Reich would have him fake an injury in order to have an excuse to bench him just doesn't make sense. Young fails, Reich fails. It's as simple as that. Frank knows this, so why would he NOT want him on the field, even if it means going through some growing pains? He's not going to fool Tepper by continually finding a new excuse to keep our #1 overall QB on the bench.

Like most conspiracy theories, this one makes little to no sense. You don't think Frank Reich realizes that if Bryce fails his career as a head coach is over? What would be the point of trying to hide him like this when even a playoff berth with Andy Dalton at QB wouldn't save Reich in the long run if Bryce ends up being a bust.

Can't be too serious. He didn't seem to be limping at all on Monday night, even late in the game. Probably just a precaution.

Justin Fields... ouch.

A pointless segment. They're just arguing the same stuff from pre-draft about his size. I maintain that we did not make a mistake drafting Bryce, but we may have made a HUGE one by hiring Frank Reich.

Burns and Zavala are disappointing. I was really encouraged by Zavala last week. Burns has to be better if he wants to be paid. If he can't consistently make an impact in this defense he's not worth his asking price.

You really think Bryce doesn't know that he's not supposed to line up under the right guard? Come on.

He's a former Heisman winner; I think he knows not to line up over the right guard.

I don't get the sense that Bryce is struggling with learning the offense. My concern is that the problem might be the offense Reich is trying to run.

That anticipation throw to Thielen that was picked off out of bounds is the perfect example of this. Bryce threw where he was supposed to, but the defender literally ran the route for the receiver.

This. The NFL season really begins in Week 5. Remember when we started 3-0 under Matt Rhule and thought we had fixed Sam Darnold? How'd that turn out? That said, it wouldn't shock me if Baker ends up being good for them. Let's not forget he was the #1 overall pick; there IS talent there. But I feel pretty sure by the end of the year he'll revert to form.

The Giants still have the stench of Gettleman all over them.

Absurd logic. The Saints are, on paper, the best team in the division. A loss wouldn't mean much of anything in the big picture.

You mean he's NOT the second coming of Earl Campbell who we should have signed to a 20-year, $500M contract?!? Blasphemy!

People act like we're paying Milles Sanders $25M/year.

Chinn. Is. Overrated.

In a heartbeat.

Without a 1st round pick it's going to be tough to get a true #1 WR in the draft. That leaves free agency (Tee Higgins is likely to be the best available) or trading for a veteran. Personally, I'd call up the Seahawks and see what it'd take to get D.K. Metcalf.

I'd like to think that's not him. But I've been wrong before.