fivethirtyeight: How good is Andrew Luck? (and Cam Newton)

[teeray]

Do the Colts still play indoors at home?

[Ruff]

Luck is good.

 

Cam is good.

 

Can we move on?

[Cary Kollins]

Luck is good.

 

Cam is good.

 

Can we move on?

 

 

 

HOW DARE YOU

[Razeyfingers]

Well, everyone in the media has declared the Panthers as having the worst WRs in the NFL and one of the worst O-lines.

So if Cam has a good season, or better season than Luck (again) statistically, we should all be able to agree on what is obvious. Cam >>>>>> Luck.

If Cam struggles, clearly they will make the same excuses for him that they have Luck every year.

 

Theyre gonna say "Man Avant has turned into a real stud and is really paying off for the Panthers" and they probably wont be wrong but Im sure Cam will get thumbed again. Pretty sure its going to keep happening until the Panthers are a household name for "oh poo, I dont wanna play those guys again"

[nctarheel0619]

Dumb question.  Would you guys say Hilton was better than Smitty last year?  

[teeray]

Dumb question. Would you guys say Hilton was better than Smitty last year?

Hard to tell with every pass to Hilton being at his ankles last year.

[Cary Kollins]

Dumb question.  Would you guys say Hilton was better than Smitty last year?  

 

 

 

yes and it's not even close

[nctarheel0619]

yes and it's not even close

 

Just curious.  I concur actually.  

[Fiz]

The fact of the matter is that theyre both good and and theyre both stars. Theyre different players, Id take Cam, shrug whatever.

There are many factors, supporting cast included, which make it difficult to isolate and statistically quantify individual qb performance. 538 is a statistics site, originally for politics then baseball, so this is what he's saying.

Nate silver is literally one of the smartest sports and stat minds in the world. His political predictions are almost perfect, and he's made some jaw dropping sports predictions, famously predicting a Tampa bay rays World Series run before the season started.

Calling him stupid makes you look like the drooling simian you are.

[Montsta]

There are many factors, supporting cast included, which make it difficult to isolate and statistically quantify individual qb performance. 538 is a statistics site, originally for politics then baseball, so this is what he's saying.

Nate silver is literally one of the smartest sports and stat minds in the world. His political predictions are almost perfect, and he's made some jaw dropping sports predictions, famously predicting a Tampa bay rays World Series run before the season started.

Calling him stupid makes you look like the drooling simian you are.

The TB prediction was before this 2104 baseball season?

[Fiz]

The TB prediction was before this 2104 baseball season?

Nah, the year they went.

[teeray]

There are many factors, supporting cast included, which make it difficult to isolate and statistically quantify individual qb performance. 538 is a statistics site, originally for politics then baseball, so this is what he's saying.

Nate silver is literally one of the smartest sports and stat minds in the world. His political predictions are almost perfect, and he's made some jaw dropping sports predictions, famously predicting a Tampa bay rays World Series run before the season started.

Calling him stupid makes you look like the drooling simian you are.

I don't think Silver actually wrote the article, although I agree Silver is incredibly smart.

A great p0ker player too

Since when did p0ker become a forbidden word

[Fiz]

I don't think Silver actually wrote the article, although I agree Silver is incredibly smart.

A great pok*r player at one time too

Since when did p0ker become a forbidden word

Regardless which one of those autistics spergs wrote it, they're whatever the opposite of stupid is.

[Proudiddy]

Luck has a weak supporting cast, he carried them, really?

 

Well he sure carried them right out of the playoffs his first year with 0 touchdowns and 2 turnovers against Baltimore.

LOL, yeah I'm wondering if they noticed we had the worst WR corps in all of football for Cam's entire career this far, he's had among THE WORST OLs each year (as a unit), and has not had his entire RB unit available to him either?

 

ehh, I'll just ignore all of that, as well as that other HUGE elephant in the room.