You want Fox and Jake gone... what about Hurney?

[PanthersFanNY]

Yeah, Hurney has done great!

No depth. Overpaid players. No first round pick. No cap room.

All I could ever want in a GM.

[Pimpdaddy]

Hurney has'nt done a bad job. the only bone i can see is Davis....why take Davis at a safety and turn him into an LB....3 year turn around when we could have just drafted an LB. WTF..... I retract my statement that Hurney is Fox foreskin...he's really jus Fox sack sweat....

[Kevin Greene]

Stewart

Beason

Davis

Johnson

Gamble

Gross

Kalil

Wharton

Otah

Peppers

Witherspoon

I think he has done a decent job

That's a fairly short list considering Spoon and Pep go back to 2002. I wouldn't put Stewart on that list but I would add Dwill.

[AKPantherFan]

What is the consensus on Marty Hurney? I personally have no issues with the guy, he usually nails the first round pick, does a good job with our cap and signing talent. Even if Fox is gone, I would prefer Hurney as our GM

Hmm lets see....

hE HAS mortgaged the future 2 years in a row, paid one man a 5 men salary and left this team with NO DEPTH ....

If this season fails, its over for hurney. Give me someone who has a fire to prove something to the nfl.

[fitty76]

That's a fairly short list considering Spoon and Pep go back to 2002. I wouldn't put Stewart on that list but I would add Dwill.

And those guys he brought up are all 1st and 2nd round picks. Where are Hurney's late round players that are making an impact on this team? Captain Munnerlyn? Anyone will tell you that the late round players are where GMs make their money.

[thunderraiden]

Hurney's drafting has hurt this team more than Jake and Fox.

we should really be able to enlarge avatars....

i was going to defend hurney.. but as i was writing my post i realized he let muhammud go a year before we went to the NFCCG and it might have actually cost us that year out of all years.

[beastson]

In short... clean house

[rayzor]

fox/hurney package deal unless hurney shows he has the balls to fire fox.

theirs and jakes futures are intertwined.

maybe keep him on to handle the cap but i'd just rather clean house and do it right.

[frash.exe]

he's only a part of the Greater Ghidorah of Mediocrity

you eliminate one you must eliminate them all

[2plankingpanther]

I guess he's done alright,but the trying to get 1st round picks for Peppers and nobody was biting wasn't smart!the Patriots wanted him,he should have lowered it to 2nd round picks and sent him on his way,if that didn't work,a2nd and 4th,anything to get him outta here!Instead,they are paying $17M+,maybe $19M for a primadonna that plays half ass for our team,our season might already be over,bench him,screw him,I hope he gets a lousy contract w/another team!He has done great(Pep)for our team in the past,but for that much $$,he is a worthless bum!The Panthers need to learn to cut players that aren't worth the boatload of $$ it takes to keep them!If peppers decides to play like superman,I'll change my tune,but til then he is being pretty stupid for playing 1/2 assed and it will come back and bite him in the ass!:nono:

[goodoleboy]

Anyone who has ever said... "With the talent we have on this team _____________" has no right to bitch about Hurney. He is responsible for getting it here. That said I think we can do better. I also don't think we are very talented right now and that the team has performed above the talent level during the Fox era.

[jramsey4]

Anyone who has ever said... "With the talent we have on this team _____________" has no right to bitch about Hurney. He is responsible for getting it here. That said I think we can do better. I also don't think we are very talented right now and that the team has performed above the talent level during the Fox era.

The problem with our team is depth. We have no depth at either lines, which IMHO are the two most important groups in football. The reason we have no depth is poor late round drafting and Pep's huge salary. Both of which are his fault. We have never tried to get a early round QB to groom behind Jake. He is just not that good a GM all around. We can do better.

[ClawOn]

I assumed this thread was a joke until I opened it. As ultimate decision maker of personnel, Hurney is the most responsible for this team's failure. I'd give Fox the silver and Peppers the bronze. Honorable mention to Jake of course.

[Mr. Scot]

Conventional wisdom is that Fox and Hurney are a package deal. One goes, the other is likely also gone.