hurney vs gettleman from 2009 to 2016

[juliosantos]

• gettleman finds 
• star- good 
• kk-ELITE
• kb-good
• turner- ELITE
• shaq- good
• bradberry- good 

 

hurney 

• captain -good
• hardy -elite
• cam-elite
• luke -elite
• norman -elite

 

Gettleman found more consistent players then hurney but hurney found more elite players . take it as you want but id rather have the elite players then good players 

[Hogmolliesmaht]

That's a lazy  comparison. Now go and look at rounds 2-7 in all of Hurney's drafts and look at all the stupid trades he made that screwed up the next 1 or 2 drafts in advance.

[juliosantos]

2 minutes ago, Hogmolliesmaht said:

That's a lazy  comparison. Now go and look at rounds 2-7 in all of Hurney's drafts and look at all the stupid trades he made that screwed up the next 1 or 2 drafts in advance.

look at daves too trading all those picks for funchess wasting a 2nd on kony ealy when we could have had jarvis landry , wheres bene and tre boston? what about zach sanchez? wasting a first rd pick on a dt when thats our strongest group other then linebacker? dave sucked just as bad as hurney  only thing he did was be cheap and did it bring us a superbowl no 

[juliosantos]

5 minutes ago, Hogmolliesmaht said:

That's a lazy  comparison. Now go and look at rounds 2-7 in all of Hurney's drafts and look at all the stupid trades he made that screwed up the next 1 or 2 drafts in advance.

maybe if he wasnt so cheap when it came to tackle we would have won the superbowl but instead remmers got cam killed 

[thefuzz]

1 minute ago, juliosantos said:

maybe if he wasnt so cheap when it came to tackle we would have won the superbowl but instead remmers got cam killed 

Which one would you have gotten, specifically?

[GoobyPls]

If you Compare their first 4 seasons they are pretty similar. Difference is Gettleman had a franchise QB handed to him on a silver platter, Hurney didn't.

[Hogmolliesmaht]

2 minutes ago, juliosantos said:

maybe if he wasnt so cheap when it came to tackle we would have won the superbowl but instead remmers got cam killed 

What tackle was he supposed to sign or draft? We were actually in pretty decent shape as far as starters anyway. Most teams would have struggled just like we did with that many injuries to one position group. As far as GM's go, it's not even a close race. Gentleman was way better than Hurney.

[E CaT PanTHer 2]

you're also comparing a GM who did it for 4 years compared to someone who did it for 11. 

 

[Cary Kollins]

2010  NFL Draft, Round 3: New England → Carolina (D). New England traded this selection to Carolina for a 2011 second-round selection.

 

Hurney traded a 2nd round pick to move up and draft ARMANTI EDWARDS in the THIRD ROUND

 

LLLLLLLLLLLLLOOOOOOOLLLLLLLLLLL

 

fml

[Mr. Scot]

Can't leave out guys like Norwell.

And Hardy's designation should be "dumbass".

[Hogmolliesmaht]

1 minute ago, E CaT PanTHer 2 said:

you're also comparing a GM who did it for 4 years compared to someone who did it for 11. 

 

Yeah, I think it's safe to say that Gettleman was well on his way to having a great 10 year run if he had been given the chance.

[Cary Kollins]

2011 draft:

Cam Newton (almost every player in that top ten is an elite player)

Terrell McClain

Sione Fua

Brandon Hogan

Kealoha Pilares

Lawrence Wilson

Zack Williams

Lee Ziemba

Byron Bell (undrafted)

 

Way to help out Cam

 

 

 

 

[KB_fan]

20 minutes ago, juliosantos said:

• gettleman finds 
• star- good 
• kk-ELITE
• kb-good
• turner- ELITE
• shaq- good
• bradberry- good 

Norwell?

Coleman?  (ok, not a "find" but he was a great fit in our system, took his play up another level when he got here.  )

[KB_fan]

22 minutes ago, juliosantos said:

norman -elite

In my opinion, Norman wasn't elite at the beginning, so you can't yet compare him to bradberry or other 2nd or even 3rd year players.