Would you trade Williams for Big Ben?

[TheSaint]

Also, think of how much better Ben would be behind our offensive line, and with our running backs (well, minus Williams assuming we traded him).

We would have the potential to be an offensive powerhouse.

i think so. you need another receiver though

[CharlotteBeer.com]

i think so. you need another receiver though

I agree. But at the same time, who's to say he can't make some of our younger guys look good (Moore, Jarrett, Barnidge, etc.)?

For the record, I think Moore will work out pretty well for us and can do the same. I'm just saying, if you've got a shot at a franchise quarterback like Ben, you take it.

[RockyTopVol]

I believe we are a WR away from being that offensive powerhouse. Big Ben isn't the missing link for this team.

I believe Moore will be a good QB. Good QBs will suffice in this league with good players at every other position. We need to address those needs first.

[coxc63]

Also, think of how much better Ben would be behind our offensive line, and with our running backs (well, minus Williams assuming we traded him).

We would have the potential to be an offensive powerhouse.

Heard this before about the possibility of getting B. Marsh. Not every big name player will make us an offensive powerhouse. We have Moore and we don't need a rapist on the team, this is similar to the trade rumors for vick. So why want a rapist who has proven himself over a dog killer who has proveb himself?

[CatMan72]

No, for the very same reasons the Steelers are looking to trade him.

[TheSaint]

Give up your 2nd round pick and get Lance Moore.

[Lumps]

He is a franchise QB.

Yes one from the draft would be way cheaper, but it would have to be a high first so something would have to go to get it. On second thought Ben would be alright here...he is not as old as I thought but Moore is much cheaper.

[necroplasm]

Why give them Williams?? They will take a 3rd and maybe another 3rd next year.

[TheSaint]

Good QBs will suffice in this league with good players at every other position. We need to address those needs first.

Moore is far from proven as a "good QB" thus far.

[TheSaint]

Why give them Williams?? They will take a 3rd and maybe another 3rd next year.

well hey...get what you can. lol

[necroplasm]

well hey...get what you can. lol

That's about what they will ask for... I'm sure. Hopefully...

[TheSaint]

Yes one from the draft would be way cheaper, but it would have to be a high first so something would have to go to get it. On second thought Ben would be alright here...he is not as old as I thought but Moore is much cheaper.

You mean like Alex Smith? Matt Leinart?

There are no guarantees in the draft.

[CharlotteBeer.com]

Heard this before about the possibility of getting B. Marsh. Not every big name player will make us an offensive powerhouse. We have Moore and we don't need a rapist on the team, this is similar to the trade rumors for vick. So why want a rapist who has proven himself over a dog killer who has proveb himself?

Might have something to do with Ben not being proven guilty in a court of law.

How many "good" quarterbacks have won Super Bowls in recent years? Hell, most of the teams that have even gone have been led by elite quarterbacks.

Yes, it's a team sport, but the quarterback is the most important position in the game today. If you have a shot at a young quarterback who already has won two Super Bowls, I think you take it and hope he keeps himself out of trouble.

[CatfanMO]

Never feed the trolls.