Benn or Tate

[Ja Rhule]

Who would you pick and why?

Benn

Tate

[DOUBLETROUBLE33]

I think I like Benn better but I would be happy with either. I think Benn is a little bit bigger and has better balance and lateral movement. I think he's a little better at breaking tackles.

[The Saltman]

benn

[Kurb]

Gilyard/Williams/Mitchell can be part of this conversation as well.

Tate is ...weird and Benn can't catch a cold. (Think Braylon Edwards)

[Panthro]

based solely on the music in each video I would say Tate.

[ammofan]

Golden Tate

[Brandon]

Benn seems like the better blocker, plus he's a better compliment to what we already have on the team.

[Yaboychris28]

tate easy

[Guild]

Tate.

Benn is bigger and probably a better run blocker which as we know is important for Carolina WRs. However, Tate is a little fighter. Think Munnerlyn except a higher pick and on offense.

The Smith comparisons are also obvious, and I believe that if he keeps a good work ethic he may improve to be a nice Smith/Welkeresque type threat.

[Kurb]

Benn

http://walterfootball.com/scoutingreport2010abenn.php

Tate

http://walterfootball.com/scoutingreport2010gtate.php

Considering what we NEED and that is an heir to the 89 Kingdom. Benn has the upside and in theory could be the better long term WR.

I would like another WR picked up in round 4 or 6.

[OneBadassCat]

Benn looks like he might be a better option to take consistent advantage of the coverage that Smith gets and a better blocker. However Tate looks like the better playmaker to me. When I see Tate I see alot Steve Smith in him and it kind of makes him too hard to pass up. Plus Tate would be playing the greatest WR ever so naturally Smith will make Tate better. Though Tate does not look as fast as Smitty.

[TerriblePizza]

Benn seems WAY more explosive. His speed is noticeably better than Tate's. However, it looks like Tate is a more polished receiver (better routes, knowledge)

[Guild]

What I'd really like to know is which of the two has the better brain. That would be what really determines this choice for me were I working with/for the FO.

Though without that knowledge I still lean towards Tate... possibly because I'm a noob.

[Mr. Scot]

Not absolutely convinced either falls to us. Both falling would be great.

Benn is more of a true "complement" whereas Tate is kind of another Smith type.