Jump to content
  • Welcome!

    Register and log in easily with Twitter or Google accounts!

    Or simply create a new Huddle account. 

    Members receive fewer ads , access our dark theme, and the ability to join the discussion!

     

Perspective


Cyberjag

Recommended Posts

I'm pretty happy with our draft, and excited about Clausen's potential. But I was also once pretty stoked about the idea of Shelton and Foster in the same backfield. So with that in mind, here's a list of all the first and second round quarterbacks in the past 20 years.

Jeff George, 1990 1st round pick, number 1 overall

Andre Ware, 1990 1st round pick, number 7 overall

Dan McGwire, 1991 1st round pick, number 16 overall

Todd Marinovich, 1991 1st round pick, number 24 overall

Brett Favre, 1991 2nd round pick, number 32 overall

Browning Nagle, 1991 2nd round pick, number 33 overall

David Klingler, 1992 1st round pick, number 6 overall

Tommy Maddox, 1992 1st round pick, number 25 overall

Dave Brown, 1992 1st round pick, number 29 overall

Matt Blundin, 1992 2nd round pick, number 40 overall

Tony Sacca, 1992 2nd round pick, number 46 overall

Drew Bledsoe, 1993 1st round pick, number 1 overall

Rick Mirer, 1993 1st round pick, number 2 overall

Heath Shuler, 1994 1st round pick, number 3 overall

Trent Dilfer, 1994 1st round pick, number 6 overall

Steve McNair, 1995 1st round pick, number 3 overall

Kerry Collins, 1995 1st round pick, number 5 overall

Todd Collins, 1995 2nd round pick, number 45 overall

Kordell Stewart, 1995 2nd round pick, number 60 overall

Tony Banks, 1996 2nd round pick, number 42 overall

Jim Druckenmiller, 1997 1st round pick, number 26 overall

Jake Plummer, 1997 2nd round pick, number 42 overall

Peyton Manning, 1998 1st round pick, number 1 overall

Ryan Leaf, 1998 1st round pick, number 2 overall

Charlie Batch, 1998 2nd round pick, number 60 overall

Tim Couch, 1999 1st round pick, number 1 overall

Donovan McNabb, 1999 1st round pick, number 2 overall

Akili Smith, 1999 1st round pick, number 3 overall

Daunte Culpepper, 1999 1st round pick, number 11 overall

Cade McNown, 1999 1st round pick, number 12 overall

Shaun King, 1999 2nd round pick, number 50 overall

Chad Pennington, 2000 1st round pick, number 18 overall

Michael Vick, 2001 1st round pick, number 1 overall

Drew Brees, 2001 2nd round pick, number 32 overall

Quincy Carter, 2001 2nd round pick, number 53 overall

Marques Tuiasosopo, 2001 2nd round pick, number 59 overall

David Carr, 2002 1st round pick, number 1 overall

Joey Harrington, 2002 1st round pick, number 3 overall

Patrick Ramsey, 2002 1st round pick, number 32 overall

Carson Palmer, 2003 1st round pick, number 1 overall

Byron Leftwich, 2003 1st round pick, number 7 overall

Kyle Boller, 2003 1st round pick, number 19 overall

Rex Grossman, 2003 1st round pick, number 22 overall

Eli Manning, 2004 1st round pick, number 1 overall

Philip Rivers, 2004 1st round pick, number 4 overall

Ben Roethlisberger, 2004 1st round pick, number 11 overall

J. P. Losman, 2004 1st round pick, number 22 overall

Alex Smith, 2005 1st round pick, number 1 overall

Aaron Rodgers, 2005 1st round pick, number 24 overall

Jason Campbell, 2005 1st round pick, number 25 overall

Vince Young, 2006 1st round pick, number 6 overall

Matt Leinart, 2006 1st round pick, number 10 overall

Jay Cutler, 2006 1st round pick, number 11 overall

Kellen Clemens, 2006 2nd round pick, number 49 overall

Tavaris Jackson, 2006 2nd round pick, number 64 overall

Jamarcus Russell, 2007 1st round pick, number 1 overall

Brady Quinn, 2007 1st round pick, number 22 overall

Kevin Kolb, 2007 2nd round pick, number 36 overall

John Beck, 2007 2nd round pick, number 40 overall

Drew Stanton, 2007 2nd round pick, number 43 overall

Matt Ryan, 2008 1st round pick, number 3 overall

Joe Flacco, 2008 1st round pick, number 18 overall

Brian Brohm, 2008 2nd round pick, number 56 overall

Chad Henne, 2008 2nd round pick, number 57 overall

Matt Stafford, 2009 1st round pick, number 1 overall

Mark Sanchez, 2009 1st round pick, number 5 overall

Josh Freeman, 2009 1st round pick, number 17 overall

Pat White, 2009 2nd round pick, number 44 overall

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Are you mocking your own posts?

lol.

I see about 18 QB's on there I would deem "OK." I see about 6-8 that are pretty damn good.

Is it just me or has there been more success with 1st round QB's lately (according to this)?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The takeaway from the list of QB's is that it IS a total crap shoot.

Now you udnerstand why Fox and Co never wanted to take a QB with a 1st rd pick. Lock up tons of money with a very high bust rate.

Risk vs. Reward

How many 1st rounders would you have wasted just to get the chance to grab Manning 1, Rivers, Brees...etc.

You may set your team back a few years if you don't get a good one, but what if you do? You have the hardest position on the field locked up for the next 12-15 years.

IMO the risk of never having an elite QB, is not worth the risk of possibly drafting a bust at the position.

Especially if you are a defensive guru like Fox is heralded to be, you should be able to field a team that is good enough on D to make up for a washout first rounder at the QB position.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


  • PMH4OWPW7JD2TDGWZKTOYL2T3E.jpg

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Took cash out for 84 before the usa game. Didn't like the corners. If this one hits will probably put 100 on Arizona to cover and the over against Purdue 
    • This is so much more than rankings.  Got tired of same old topics.  I see the thread beginning, "Breaking News: Panthers...." and then I open it and read the complete title of the thread "...OT Jordan Gross Retires."  So here is something to chew on:  Don't hurt my feelings.  LZ rates the bounty of talent at each position and I provide a quote from his article.  It changed my approach. https://www.nfl.com/news/ranking-11-position-groups-in-2026-nfl-draft-from-strongest-to-weakest-edge-rusher-linebacker-loaded #1: Edge: Lance predicts the Edge position will, once again, dominate the first round and it is the strongest position.  If the Panthers draft an edge on day 1 or day 2, Wow.  Phillips, Scourton, Princely, Jones, along with Hampton, Gipson, and Incoom.  Personally, I think we are going to let the others grab the Edge players forcing other positions to drop to us.  This strategy does not discount the fact that if a stud edge falls to 19… LZ:  “This class figures to provide a strong number of future starters, with as many as 17 players poised to come off the board in the first three rounds, but the quality of depth will trail off on Day 3. The edge defenders will rule the first round.” #2 Linebacker:  The Panthers added a starting Mike ILB in free agency, but the rest of the roster is depth. The need is for an off-ball LB who can cover.  Since it is my opinion that we draft a STARTER here, I would expect a first- or second-round pick  However, he makes a comment about the depth, suggesting that quality players could be found on early day 3. LZ: “Anthony Hill Jr. is a talented three-down option who could go on Day 1, while Jake Golday, CJ Allen and Jacob Rodriguez look like Round 2 selections as potential early starters. The linebacker group stays strong in Rounds 3 and 4, with decent depth stretching into the fifth round.” #3. Interior Offensive Line:  This one surprised me, powered by some guards that could go as early as round 2.  Remember, LZ is rating these positions based on projected starters.  He mentions that Center is strong based on short-armed OTs that will transition to center, claiming that starters can be found into the fifth round.  That is good news for the Panthers, who do not really need an immediate starter, but they need a future starter who can play a few years on a rookie contract. LZ: “Meanwhile, Connor Lew, Sam Hecht, Logan Jones and Brian Parker II could all become future starting centers, while Trey Zuhn III might not be far behind. The number of starters and the depth into Round 5 is what helps this group stand out.” #4. Wide Receiver:   Finding potential starters at WR is probably easier than C, but let’s not assume that WR is not a need in Charlotte.  TMac needs someone who can keep defenses from cheating in coverage.  Coker is very promising, but the others? I get the feeling that they are hoping XL comes around in year 3.  Regardless, if a WR is there that makes them better, they could pull the trigger–again–just not in round 1.  If the Panthers grab a WR, it will be for a 3rd-5th WR, which makes LZ’s comment interesting: LZ:  “In terms of starting talent, this offering is a little softer than those from some recent years, but there will be plenty of quality depth for WR3/4 roles inside of the first five rounds.” #5 Cornerback:  Yes, we have Horn and Jackson (in his final year at age 29) and Smith-Wade has been fairly good. Thornton was the second-rated rookie CB before his injury last year.  Could we use depth at nickel?  An outside CB?  I think we could add both, frankly. Future starters.  I love the nickel from Duke, who is not mentioned.   LZ:  “The depth at wide corner is lacking, but there are some very talented nickelbacks who will step into starting roles fairly quickly, including Avieon Terrell, Treydan Stukes, D'Angelo Ponds and Keionte Scott. It's worth noting that this might be the fastest cornerback group, from top to bottom, that we've ever seen.” #6(T) Safety: This prognosis could be why we re-signed Scott. However, it could also foreshadow why we might take a safety in rounds 1 or 2.  In my view, I think the value at S is not comparable, per round, to the value at other positions.  Remember the comment about moving Smith-Wade to safety?  I wonder if that was a stupid comment or someone in the know spewing inside info.  I want a safety, but I am not crazy about them in this draft. LZ:  “Ballhawking safeties like Bud Clark and A.J. Haulcy offer future starting value in the second round, as does Jalen Kilgore, who is a big, explosive down safety. I'm also a fan of VJ Payne from Kansas State, but in general, this group becomes average, depth-level talent fairly quickly on Day 3.” #6 (T) Tight End:  Sadiq is not described as elite, but could be a first-rounder.  Frankly, from the sounds of this, it is either reach for Sadiq in round 1 or wait until round 3.  I am not seeing a TE in this draft.  I know the Panthers want one, but how much?   LZ: (After Sadiq round 1)--We might not see many second-round TE picks, but this group is fairly deep in Rounds 3 through 5, featuring some solid pass catchers and a very strong run blocker in Sam Roush out of Stanford. The 2026 draft could produce a sneaky-high number of tight ends who earn second NFL contracts.” #8 (T) Defensive Line: This group is hard to gauge, and drafting one where the Panthers pick seems a bit awkward on day 1.  Nobody is worth #19 and the elite DTs will be long gone by #53 or whatever.  However, I like some of the second-tier players.  It seems NTs are abundant, but 3Ts are in short supply.  Maybe a player like Holten or Jackson in round 3 or (sleeper) Capehart around 3-4. LZ:  (Borderline first-rounders:  Banks, McDonald, Woods)  “Beyond that talented trio, the position offers a series of future starters/rotational contributors on Day 2.” #8 (T) Offensive Tackle:  Yikes.  LZ is not really high on this group, and he provides reasons.  My take?  Many are good pass protectors, but struggie in run support. Walker is seeming like a great signing right now.  I think we grab the RT later, but LZ’s comments about mid round talent demonstrates that there is a lot of risk from top to bottom this year.  Personally, I think we might draft Parker early or Crownover later. LZ: Top prospects like Francis Mauigoa and Spencer Fano come with shorter-than-desired arms, while the gargantuan Kadyn Proctor is coming off a highly uneven season in pass protection. Caleb Lomu, Monroe Freeling and Max Iheanachor all have talent but are less polished than teams might like. There is an adequate number of starting-caliber bookends available early, but it becomes highly speculative for teams hunting quality depth by the middle of the third round. 10: Running Back.  Pass 11.  (Last) Quarterback:  This may be a place to find a developmental gem, an emergency QB who has longshot potential to compete should Bryce fail.  If people feel that this class is as bad as LZ suggests, could a gem fall into undrafted free agent status?   I think I would watch that dynamic. LZ;  Ty Simpson has a chance to become an NFL starter, but this is a below-average quarterback class with a low number of future starters and quality backups to choose from. It wouldn't shock me to see QB-hungry teams kick the can down the road and wait until next year.”   READING THE TEA LEAVES:  Of course, this is not to suggest that Lance Zierlein knows all and sees all.  But I will say that he is a good talent evaluator and he talks to the people in the front offices that we do not have access to.  We are often misled by hacks making crap up to get clicks and hits–and this is part of that environment, so “grain of salt.”   After reading this, I had the following thoughts: Taking an OT in round 1 seems like a mistake under most circumstances.  I think we need to find a RT to develop later in the draft.  I think we will add someone like Jude Bowery from Boston College in round 4.  I think we need to look at OT on both sides as if we have 1 year to groom a starter. If there is a run on Edges, a solid WR will be sitting there.  We could have a situation where the BPAs at #19 are either an edge or WR.  How would an elite WR help us?   At safety, if a team falls in love with Oregon FS Thienemen, the lack of depth behind him could force a reach. Could Carolina be that team?   The Panthers signed a decent C to a one-year contract. Centers with eventual starting ability can be found in rounds 3, 4, and even 5. Expect the Panthers to draft a center in round 4.  Yes, round 4.  I even predict Brian Parker from Duke.  Eerie, huh? We will be drafting a LB early, but I am guessing second round.  The next panther starting W ILB is going to be Rodriguez or Golday.  Madly on fire with my specific predictions–in round 2. Tight End?  Unless we dive in early, I do not see the upgrade.  I am willing to predict that we don’t draft a TE. Cornerback:  We will add a CB, probably a nickel (where there is value) late.  Defensive Line: Depending on what happens in round 1, Defensive line could be a late day 2 pick.   This may shock some of you.  I live on the edge.   ROUND 1:  Best value:  Edge, Wide Receiver, Cornerback.  I predict overdrafting OT and a run on edge will drop WRs and maybeCB  lower and a great value could land in our lap.  Could we do it again?  In the words of Brittany Spears, “Oops.” Corner?  Well, I think we will move Smith-Wade to FS at some point.  Smart, calls coverages.  Jackson is gone after 2026. . Get a nickel later, however, unless a stud CB falls. Please don’t draft TE here. Edge?  On paper, we are strong, but you can never have enough pass rushers.  We will leave awesome at one position that we may not have listed as a primary need: Edge, CB, or WR. ROUND 2:  Best Value: Linebacker.  I do not see us drafting another position here.  LB–Hill (longshot), Rodgriguez, Golday. Edge (second tier–Height, Jacas, Moore, Young, Howell–would be hard to overlook, but our GM is a former LB)  S A Haulcy is a darkhorse possibility. ROUND 3:  Best Value:  Defensive line. Halton (OK), Jackson (Fl. St), Durant (Penn State).   ROUND 4:  Best Value: Center.  Slaughter, Hecht, Jones, Lew, Coogan, Jones, Zuhn.  This is the only real option.  We should take our center in round 4. ROUND 5:  Best value:  They will be looking for a developmental OT here if not addressed sooner.  Jude Bowery ((BC), D. Crownover (RT-Tex AM), Wagner (RT-Notre Dame) seem promising.   
    • Spot-on. D-line and FS are much bigger immediate needs than OT or WR. Look at the current roster and the fact that they have not brought in any new players at those positions. 
×
×
  • Create New...