Schefter's facts are wrong

[CatMan72]

This all assumes of course that Luck could be anything like Peyton Manning, which is a pretty big assumption.

It's important to note that Scouts, Inc. gave Leinart the same grade the year he came out as they have given Luck this year... not saying Luck won't be great, but it's far from a sure thing no matter how good he looks right now.

[TANTRIC-NINJA]

Lol @ everyone on a message board who hates every "expert" Schefter, Florio, Glazer, Mortenson all have good well connected sources...people change their minds and are also allowed to make mistakes.

But not on the Huddle. You are on a message board... Schefter is one of the best insiders in my opinion. He was better on NFL network but still one of the best.

U need to turn your rage to the Charlotte beat writers who all get their info from Schefter, Florio, Glazer. they seem to get better insight that Darrian Gant, and the local poop paper.

[Happy Panther]

This all assumes of course that Luck could be anything like Peyton Manning, which is a pretty big assumption.

It's important to note that Scouts, Inc. gave Leinart the same grade the year he came out as they have given Luck this year... not saying Luck won't be great, but it's far from a sure thing no matter how good he looks right now.

#1 QBs fall into 3 categories. Roughly equal i would say but I'm not going to count it up

Bust - Jamarcus. Carr

Good - Stafford Plamer

HOF franchise QB - Manning, Aikman, Vick, Bledsoe

If your team has a huge hole at QB and a chance to fill that hole with category #3 above it is huge. Luck not declaring is a massive blow to the panthers.

[mav1234]

Luck not declaring is a blow but there are still other options that could end up legit #1s by the time the draft rolls around.

The Luck Hype really buried other QBs. They are just now being examined better.

[48ochoshogun]

Adams been wrong all week

[TarPanther9180]

Lol @ everyone on a message board who hates every "expert" Schefter, Florio, Glazer, Mortenson all have good well connected sources...people change their minds and are also allowed to make mistakes.

But not on the Huddle. You are on a message board... Schefter is one of the best insiders in my opinion. He was better on NFL network but still one of the best.

U need to turn your rage to the Charlotte beat writers who all get their info from Schefter, Florio, Glazer. they seem to get better insight that Darrian Gant, and the local poop paper.

I hate all them too

[Ricky Spanish]

just checked, jawalrus had a 98 overall grade just like luck. And Alex Smith. and Matt Leinert...

VY and brady quinn got 97s

Scouts inc gave clausen an 89 but kiper gave him a 93 or so while josh freeman got an 85

I've come to the conclusion that Kiper is a retard and can't evaluate QBs worth a poo.

I will now base my opinions on QBs by my own observations/feelings because I have a better track record of picking these guys than he does.

[Peppers90 NC]

Yeah? Last night some host on sportscenter call us the South Carolina Panthers.

they had to be mocking us then.

[TarPanther9180]

Don't draft Newton! Why? Because he is a Heisman trophy winner...those guys are cursed (jury still out on Bradford).

[bigmanstew]

It would have been interesting if Manning had left UT in 97.

He goes to the Parcells/Belichick Jets.

Parcells might have coached a little longer, and Belichick might not have ever left the Jets for New England.

What in the world would have ever become of Tom Brady? There is no doubt he has talent, but Brady+Belichick is far better than Brady+(Any other coach), and Manning+Belichick would be a deadly combination.

Heck Meshawn Johnson might even be the hall of fame receiver his own mind thinks he already is.