Would you do this trade?

[YoungPanthers89]

nope

[panther4life]

No

[jtnc]

Jimmy Clausen

Everette Brown

Dwayne Jarrett

Richard Marshall

Eric Shelton

Evan Mathias

Keary Colbert

Bruce Nelson

vs.

Ryan Kalil

James Anderson

Sherrod Martin

So your question is would you trade a great offensive lineman for a 2nd round pick.....when the majority of your 2nd round picks turn out to suck??

Answer is no. Even if Otah can't play full seasons. He is good when he plays and that means ultimately he is a good player on the OL. OL is HUGE in the NFL. At worst he turns into good depth until his contract comes up.

I'm pretty sure James Anderson was a 3rd rounder.

[mercules20]

without a doubt, get a pass protection specialist next year in the draft, otahs a great player, but if he's never on the field who cares?

[KillerKat]

I would.

[Jackofalltrades]

Moronic even in theory.

No one in their right mind would give up anything near a 2nd for any player that is injury prone.

That being said- Oakland's Al Davis is who I'd ask.

[Mother Grabber]

Bears already have an OT from that draft who has trouble staying on the field...

[Grammer]

no one in their right mind would give a second rounder for a fat fug injury prone OT

[Jackofalltrades]

no one in their right mind would give a second rounder for a fat fug injury prone OT

He gets paid rather well to be big, he's not near as fat as you'd think btw.

[jtnc]

Eagles maybe desperate to make this deal, they have TWO seconds.

[SeaMonster]

A second is a no-brainer. Might take less.

[Marguide]

He gets paid rather well to be big, he's not near as fat as you'd think btw.

Exactly. What do people expect OL to look like? Wharton is not exactly svelte and no one is complaining about his eating habits. Or how about Byron Bell?

I sometimes question Otah's desire to get on the field, but the whole fat thing is way off base.

[o_O]

I'd give them Otah for a 1st & Hester. Nothing more, nothing less.

[MadHatter]

no one in their right mind would give a second rounder for a fat fug injury prone OT

Another fine example of how you just can't fix stupid.