2 teams give you two offers saturday...

[frash.exe]

which one do you take, team A's offer or team B's?

[bleys]

team B... hands down.

[Troy17289TD]

^this

[Panthro]

Although according to the trade charts a 1st next year ='s a 2nd this year

[carpanfan96]

Me personally team B, Fox and Hurney take team A. Just for the fact that if were trading peppers we need for him to be replaced now for this upcoming season.

[Gscottnc5]

Take both picks for this year. The league is a "what have you done for me lately" not what can you do for me next year!!! You need immediate impact players not project's, IMO.

[R0CKnR0LLA]

D) Negotiate a 2010 1st and 2009 2nd.

[frash.exe]

Although according to the trade charts a 1st next year ='s a 2nd this year

they both have their perks. On one hand, you can cash in now and we could really use a first round talent on the defensive line. Plus that extra third will permit us to get an extra depth player.

...on the other hand, you double your amount of first day picks for next year. You basically do what I like to call "team stock investing". It basically means that, say it was the Browns that gave the second offer. Depending on how good or bad the Browns are in 2009 dictates how high or low the first rounder they gave to us will be. So we could conceivably be picking in the top 10 in 2010 with the chance to trade down and accumulate even more picks. Plus, this isn't really the deepest draft in overall talent this year anyway.

the real tradeoff is time. and that's why the trade charts say what they say.

[EightyNine]

it probably depends on who they like in this years draft....

[R0CKnR0LLA]

Really depends on the where the 1st rounder is this year, and what players are available at that spot.

[panthers55]

Can't decide until we know which teams we are talking about. If it is Kansas City they may or may not be a top 10 pick next year but definitely are a number 3 pick this year. On the other hand a team like NE will be a a 23rd pick this year and likely a later pick next year. That would make a big difference. A 3 pick next year might be worth more than a number 23 pick this year.

Right now ths poll is lame without more specifics.

[2jakefansinva]

I would have to go with the picks this year. I'd be scared of staring a gift horse in the mouth. If this team could add another 1st rd. talent he could be what we need and he'd just be better next year.

[Squirrel]

One good thing either way he would be off our cap so with extra money I will go B.

[dexterpyro]

I say the picks this year as long as this year pick isnt top 10. There arent any players to take that high that we cant get a same/better player later. I dont want to play a rookie big bucks for his potential