Jump to content
  • Welcome!

    Register and log in easily with Twitter or Google accounts!

    Or simply create a new Huddle account. 

    Members receive fewer ads , access our dark theme, and the ability to join the discussion!

     

SB Nation's Safety Rankings (Panthers 30th)


Recommended Posts

NFC South Rankings

New Orleans Saints**: 14th

Atlanta Falcons: 15th

Tampa Bay Buccaneers: 28th

Carolina Panthers: 30th

30. Carolina Panthers

Carolina has mostly spare parts at safety. The spare part that might surprise is Ravens' castoff Haruki Nakamura. He is competing with Sherrod Martin for the starting free safety role. Better, healthier linebackers could help Charles Godfrey at strong safety.

No shock here, I pretty much agree with what was said. Martin just doesn't look like he has the ability to play safety and even with a strong and healthy linebacker corp; I don't see much improvement in his game. Nakamura and Smith will definitely challenge for the free safety spot. Charles Godfrey on the other hand should really benefit from a strong linebacker corp and hopefully a better secondary in general with Nakamura and Norman possibly taking over for Martin and Munnerlyn. A Gamble, Norman, Godfrey, and Nakamura secondary looks pretty good on paper, in my opinion.

Thoughts?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

NFC South Rankings

New Orleans Saints****: 14th

Atlanta Falcons: 15th

Tampa Bay Buccaneers: 28th

Carolina Panthers: 30th

No shock here, I pretty much agree with what was said. Martin just doesn't look like he has the ability to play safety and even with a strong and healthy linebacker corp; I don't see much improvement in his game. Nakamura and Smith will definitely challenge for the free safety spot. Charles Godfrey on the other hand should really benefit from a strong linebacker corp and hopefully a better secondary in general with Nakamura and Norman possibly taking over for Martin and Munnerlyn. A Gamble, Norman, Godfrey, and Nakamura secondary looks pretty good on paper, in my opinion.

Thoughts?

Thoughts?

Sounds like blind optmism in regards to Godfrey...who has consistantly been one of the worst S in the NFL since arriving. Every year a new excuse for why he can't tackle in the open field or handle coverage assignments.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Acually it doesnt look too good on paper, but thats just me bud. Gamble is solid but underrated. Norman is a rookie so he is a huge questionmark. Nakamura is also unproven. Godfrey has potential but hasnt shined quite yet. From an outsiders viewpoint we look pretty shakey in the secondary.

But i think Rivera knows what jes doing. He turned the chargers defense into the best in the league with a bunch of No names like ours.Dont forget Wilkes. But honestly i see a lot of potential

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thoughts?

Sounds like blind optmism in regards to Godfrey...who has consistantly been one of the worst S in the NFL since arriving. Every year a new excuse for why he can't tackle in the open field or handle coverage assignments.

Godfrey has been far from one of the worse safety's in the league. He looks bad at times because he is having to cover for Captain Munnerlyn or whoever is playing cornerback on the left side.

Godfrey reads routes very well and he is an above average tackler.

I don't understand all the hate Godfrey gets all the time, when he is an average NFL safety. It's not like he is fricken Brandon Meriweather, so I see no need to be pissed off about Godfrey.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Acually it doesnt look too good on paper, but thats just me bud. Gamble is solid but underrated. Norman is a rookie so he is a huge questionmark. Nakamura is also unproven. Godfrey has potential but hasnt shined quite yet. From an outsiders viewpoint we look pretty shakey in the secondary.

But i think Rivera knows what jes doing. He turned the chargers defense into the best in the league with a bunch of No names like ours.Dont forget Wilkes. But honestly i see a lot of potential

Gamble- Top 10 corner

Norman- Has really impressed so far

Nakamura- Has learned from Ed Reed

Godfrey- Very underrated corner

Doesn't look so bad to me.

People also forget that without a pass rush, any team's secondary is going to look awful. If we can get Ron Edwards back healthy and an improved McClain/Fua along with Alexander/Hardy/Johnson creating pressure on the outside; I think this secondary will have a chance to shine.

Once again, don't forget about our top three linebacker corp returning from injury.

I'm sure the Steelers secondary would look poor if their linebackers were Jason Phillips and Kion Wilson.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Godfrey is still our best safty

that's the problem

Our safety play has been horrific the past few years. 30th is likely being generous. The only thing that keeps us from being dead last is signing some free agents who may actually have a little bit of ability.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Godfrey has been far from one of the worse safety's in the league. He looks bad at times because he is having to cover for Captain Munnerlyn or whoever is playing cornerback on the left side.

Godfrey reads routes very well and he is an above average tackler.

I don't understand all the hate Godfrey gets all the time, when he is an average NFL safety. It's not like he is fricken Brandon Merriweather, so I see no need to be pissed off about Godfrey.

Godfrey has been one of the worst....if you talk to people who aren't Panther fans.

Captain is just a 2012 excuse....every year it is something else causing him to not be able to make tackles in the open field and handle his assignment in coverage.

Take a site like PFF......and find a S that has started in the NFL who has rated as poorly as Godfrey over the same time span (with the same team). There isn't one....they all get benched, cut or traded. So how is Godfrey not one the worst starting Ss in the NFL since he arrived? Bc Carolina extended him?

And Godfrey is a horrible tackler. Above average? Off what? Don't confuse a hard hit when he arrives with the ball as good tackling....in the open field Godfrey couldn't bring down my grandma.

As I have said before....ability isn't the issue as he has the tools. He just isn't a S. He will be replaced either this year or next.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Godfrey has been one of the worst....if you talk to people who aren't Panther fans.

Captain is just a 2012 excuse....every year it is something else causing him to not be able to make tackles in the open field and handle his assignment in coverage.

Take a site like PFF......and find a S that has started in the NFL who has rated as poorly as Godfrey over the same time span (with the same team). There isn't one....they all get benched, cut or traded. So how is Godfrey not one the worst starting Ss in the NFL since he arrived? Bc Carolina extended him?

When you have to cover for someone else, you are going to look like sh*t. Point blank.

In the 2010-2011 season, Godfrey was the only bright spot on the team.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

When you have to cover for someone else, you are going to look like sh*t. Point blank.

In the 2010-2011 season, Godfrey was the only bright spot on the team.

That's pretty bad because Godfrey was on of the worst safetys in the NFL that season as well. 2009 was the only season he wasn't just terrible.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

When you have to cover for someone else, you are going to look like sh*t. Point blank.

In the 2010-2011 season, Godfrey was the only bright spot on the team.

Every year the reason Godfrey sucks is blamed on someone...

His FFs that one season made him a S in some eyes he simply isn't and has never been here. Funny how Godfrey earns praise to this day ofg those FFs from one season.....yet the same people dismiss Martin's moments and pin the suckage on him.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


  • PMH4OWPW7JD2TDGWZKTOYL2T3E.jpg

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Let's say we have a LT for 2026, because we do.  After that, let's say Ickey could be back and we would have the option of extending Walker.  That too is truth.  Don't get me wrong--I LOVE drafting OL, but drafting a first-round OT now is either wasting the money we just paid for a free agent OR it is like paying top dollar for a new car and keeping it in your garage for a season.  A first rounder should give us 4-5 years of cap relief by playing from day 1. I shall elaborate here: Teams obviously get desperate for OTs and if they enter the draft without 2 solid tackles, they are almost obligated to reach for a first round OT.  This year, I see 1 OT who is probably worth first-round consideration, and I am not putting him in the top 10 players in the draft.  Lomu, Freeling, Miller, and Proctor, for example, probably and arguably have second-round value.  So why would you reach for an OT in round 1 when you already have starters at both T positions but you have other needs? We do need depth, however, and I think there is decent OT depth that needs development on day 3. They are no slouches, by the way.   Drew Shelton (could drop to round 4): Surrendered 1 sack as Penn State's LT in 2025. 33 3/8" arms.  Pass pro improved every year (4 years--experienced).  "For a team running a zone-heavy scheme that values lateral movement and reach-blocking ability over phone-booth mauling, Shelton has real appeal. He is not a plug-and-play starter, but the athletic tools and the clear year-over-year improvement suggest a player who can develop into a capable starter if a coaching staff invests in his strength base and cleans up his technique. The ceiling depends entirely on how much stronger he can get and whether his feet can stay alive after initial contact."   Austin Barber  (could drop to round 4): I see him as a RT at best and a probable kick inside to Guard where his strengths would switch from secondary to primary tools.  Considering Lewis and Hunt may be gone in a year or two, this would give the Panthers a chance to work him at RT and then move him inside if he is not effective, and there is confidence that G may be his best position. Jude Bowery (4th round projection) was LT on a Boston College OL that was effective in the run game.  Bowery is one of the most athletic OTs in the draft.  His arms are not ideal but not too short (33.75") to play LT.  He surrendered 2 sacks. He is raw, and needs some technical refinement with his hands.  I think he has the best upside and value for this offense.   Dametrious Crownover  TexAM (5th round projection; 35 3/8" arms) is one of the more fascinating developmental tackles in this class because the physical tools are legitimately rare. A strong run blocker who should be better in pass protection with his tools.  "You do not find many 6-7, 336-pound men with that foot speed and who have the athletic background of a converted tight end. When everything clicks, he looks like a starting right tackle in a gap-heavy run scheme, smothering defenders at the point of attack and using his length to erase speed off the edge. The 2024 tape, when he anchored one of the best rushing attacks in the SEC, is the version of Crownover that gets offensive line coaches excited."  THIS is the kind of player our coaches could develop until Moton is done. What made World intriguing coming out of Eugene was the untapped ceiling, a fifth-year transfer who arrived as the top-ranked offensive tackle in the portal and looked the part for stretches. The improvement he showed against Big Ten competition in his one Oregon season was real, and the physical foundation, length, athleticism, and improving technique in pass protection, is still there. The ACL tear suffered in the College Football Playoff semifinal against Indiana doesn't erase that, but it changes the conversation significantly. The injury clouds the immediate projection. Most ACL recoveries for offensive linemen run nine to twelve months, which means World is likely unavailable for meaningful action well into his rookie season at the earliest. The combine absence removes his chance to reset the narrative physically, and teams will be making decisions almost entirely off pre-injury film and medical evaluations. The contrast between his polished pass sets and his inconsistent run blocking was already a developmental concern, and now those technique issues get deferred further while he rehabs. Isaiah World  (Oregon, injured ACL in playoffs, 5th round projection--could slide to 6th).  World will not play much if at all in 2026, which is why he might fall.  For the Panthers' purposes, however, this would give the OL coaches time to work with him. "What made World intriguing coming out of Eugene was the untapped ceiling, a fifth-year transfer who arrived as the top-ranked offensive tackle in the portal and looked the part for stretches. The improvement he showed against Big Ten competition in his one Oregon season was real, and the physical foundation, length, athleticism, and improving technique in pass protection, is still there. The ACL tear suffered in the College Football Playoff semifinal against Indiana doesn't erase that, but it changes the conversation significantly." "That said, the investment argument isn't crazy for the right organization. This is still a tackle with first-round portal grades and the kind of athletic profile that doesn't just disappear. A team with patience and a strong offensive line room can afford to stash World on the roster, let him develop his lower-body power and pad-level consistency during the recovery process, and potentially unlock a starting-caliber right tackle somewhere in his second or third season. The path is longer now, but the destination hasn't changed for a scout willing to bet on the physical tools." You get the idea. If we do not need the OT immediately, draft one later and develop him as depth and for next season.  Most college players drafted in round 1 were not first rounders if they had entered the draft the year before,  so why not grab a player with upside?      
    • Its never the QBs fault, so if we get a new WR and he looks bad he must be a bust
    • Based on what? Its certainly not his in game coaching prowess. 
×
×
  • Create New...