Should we give up on a QB 25 games into his career?

[CRA]

25 games in....

QB 1:

20 starts

3-17 record

14 TDs, 31 INT, 1 rush TD

QB 2

25 starts

8- 17

29 TDs, 27 INTs, 18 rush TDs

QB 3:

18 starts

11-7 record

13 TDs, 21 INTs 1 rush TD

QB 4:

25 starts

10-15 record

43 TDs, 38 INTs, 1 rush TD

QB 5:

16 starts

7-9 record

21 TDs, 18 INTs

Most young QBs lose, most throw picks..... Cam is a work in progress.....like most. Biggest issue is people want to compare him to what HOF QBs are doing now.....instead of what they did above.

[jtnc]

Of course, it's not like Armanti Edwards has been on the team and has wasted a roster spot that other DESERVING players could use. Nah, trade Cam.

Let's stop lying to ourselves, Cam sucks. He's terrible, is it a coincidence his best year was when his offensive line was playing well? I doubt it, is it a coincidence his best season was when we didn't run option the majority of the time? I doubt it.

Conclusion: Cam sucks, trade Cam.

[Mr. Scot]

Not a guy that you spent a number 1 pick on.

[fieryprophet]

No. Hell no. Nada. Nil. Nein. Nay. Negative. Negatory. Nope. No way. No f*cking way. No way, Jose. Not on my watch. Never. Never, ever. Never ever never.

[CarolinaNut]

so basically if you say anything critical about Cam it means you've given up on him?

got it.

[nosuchthingasapanther]

give up?

no.

rely on?

no.

center an entire organization around?

no.

[jtnc]

Jay Z said it best "First they love you, then they hate you, then they love you again."

[Guest Super_Freak]

No, not with a number one pick. You sink or swim and coaches get fired.

[panther4life]

No but I would say your taking the huddle way too seriously if you felt the need to make this thread.

[theyhateme45]

No.... I think there are some here whom are not happy with his progression this year, But I still think very few are ready to give up on Cam.

[carolina-chuck]

These Cam's haters are very amusing. Very AMUSING.

[CRA]

No but I would say your taking the huddle way too seriously if you felt the need to make this thread.

The OP I made was more rhetorical and wasn't a real question.....people just are too focused on Cam. The initial post has every #1 overall QB since 1980 that panned out. It is a journey....people seem to not get that.

Aikman

Cam

Elway

P. Manning

E. Manning

[carolina-chuck]

Jay Z said it best "First they love you, then they hate you, then they love you again."

Cam should get that quote "tatted" on himself so it'll reminds him of these dumb@$$ Carolina Fans.

[TheRed]

It's all one players fault. It's not like the organization and staff is in disarray currently. People just need someone to blame and look to Cam because he's put front and center like a thanksgiving turkey.

Simple mindedness and the huddle, can't have one without the other.