Jump to content
  • Welcome!

    Register and log in easily with Twitter or Google accounts!

    Or simply create a new Huddle account. 

    Members receive fewer ads , access our dark theme, and the ability to join the discussion!

     

Can someone help me find the Newton vs manning stats?


Recommended Posts

Might as well forget it, no pats fan will listen to sound logic. I have a sister in law who is and only knows of tom brady and no one else on the team but will try to argue that cam sucks and that they made lafell. Even though both teams use different playbooks, personel, etc and that lafell was asked to do more here than there.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I made this one a while back and forgot about it. I guess this summer would be the time to catch up on all the requests:

 

 

Cam Newton:
1,144 / 1,923 (59.5%)
14,426 Passing Yards
232.7 passing yards per game
82 TDs, 54 INT
2,571 Rush Yards
33 Rush TD's
115 Total TD's
85.4 Rating
 
Tom Brady:
1242/2015 (61.6%)
13,919 Passing Yards
220.4 yards per game
97 TDs, 52 INT
244 Rush Yards
2 Rush TD's
99 Total TD's
87.5 Rating
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I love Cam but comparing him with Manning is a lost cause.

Peyton has been top 5 in passing yards and td every single year since his rookie season I believe.

 

Peyton's first 4 and Cam's first 4 years are VERY comparable if you actually look at the numbers.  And that was with Marvin Harrison, Reggie Wayne and Dallas Clark...not to mention Edgerrin James...

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Peyton Manning's first 5 yrs in NFL

age 22 - #3 in passing yds, #5 in pass TDs, #23 QB rating

age 23 - #3 in passing yds, #3 in pass TDs, #4 QB rating

age 24 - #1 in passing yds, #1 in pass TDs, #6 QB rating

age 25 - #2 in passing yds, #5 in pass TDs, #8 QB rating

age 26 - #3 in passing yds, #2 in pass TDs, #5 QB rating

Cam's first 5 yrs in NFL

age 22 - #10 in passing yds, #11 in pass TDs, #15 QB rating

age 23 - #13 in passing yds, #21 in pass TDs, #15 QB rating

age 24 - #15 in passing yds, #12 in pass TDs, #16 QB rating

age 25 - #21 in passing yds, #19 in pass TDs, #26 QB rating

age 26 - upcoming season

Colin Kaepernick's first 5 yrs in NFL

age 24 - no starts

age 25 - only 7 starts - #7 QB rating

age 26 - #20 in passing yds, #17 in pass TDs, #10 QB rating

age 27 - #17 in passing yds, #17 in pass TDs, #20 QB rating

age 28 - upcoming season

note: Kaepernick is not on the same level as Cam as a passer, yet he is the 4th-most popular player in the NFL in merchandise sales over the last year:

Andrew Luck's first 5 yrs in NFL

age 23 - #7 in passing yds, #14 in pass TDs, #26 QB rating

age 24 - #13 in passing yds, #15 in pass TDs, #18 QB rating

age 25 - #3 in passing yds, #1 in pass TDs, #7 QB rating

age 26 - upcoming season

age 27 - ?

note: Luck's first two years in the NFL weren't all that great

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Comparing raw stats from different eras is pointless. Anyone paying attention knows it's gotten easier and easier to throw the ball over the last 10-15 years. Only remotely fair comparisons are maybe their rankings against their peers in those stats but just numbers vs numbers doesn't prove anything except we're in an era catered to the passing game.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Peyton Manning's first 5 yrs in NFL

age 22 - #3 in passing yds, #5 in pass TDs, #23 QB rating

age 23 - #3 in passing yds, #3 in pass TDs, #4 QB rating

age 24 - #1 in passing yds, #1 in pass TDs, #6 QB rating

age 25 - #2 in passing yds, #5 in pass TDs, #8 QB rating

age 26 - #3 in passing yds, #2 in pass TDs, #5 QB rating

Cam's first 5 yrs in NFL

age 22 - #10 in passing yds, #11 in pass TDs, #15 QB rating

age 23 - #13 in passing yds, #21 in pass TDs, #15 QB rating

age 24 - #15 in passing yds, #12 in pass TDs, #16 QB rating

age 25 - #21 in passing yds, #19 in pass TDs, #26 QB rating

age 26 - upcoming season

Colin Kaepernick's first 5 yrs in NFL

age 24 - no starts

age 25 - only 7 starts - #7 QB rating

age 26 - #20 in passing yds, #17 in pass TDs, #10 QB rating

age 27 - #17 in passing yds, #17 in pass TDs, #20 QB rating

age 28 - upcoming season

note: Kaepernick is not on the same level as Cam as a passer, yet he is the 4th-most popular player in the NFL in merchandise sales over the last year:

Andrew Luck's first 5 yrs in NFL

age 23 - #7 in passing yds, #14 in pass TDs, #26 QB rating

age 24 - #13 in passing yds, #15 in pass TDs, #18 QB rating

age 25 - #3 in passing yds, #1 in pass TDs, #7 QB rating

age 26 - upcoming season

age 27 - ?

note: Luck's first two years in the NFL weren't all that great

as for Tom Brady's first 5 seasons in the NFL:

age 23 - did not play

age 24 - did not start full season, #6 QB rating

age 25 - #6 in passing yds, #1 in pass TDs, #9 QB rating

age 26 - #6 in passing yds, #10 in pass TDs, #10 QB rating

age 27 - #10 in passing yds, #6 in pass TDs, #9 QB rating

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Comparing raw stats from different eras is pointless. Anyone paying attention knows it's gotten easier and easier to throw the ball over the last 10-15 years. Only remotely fair comparisons are maybe their rankings against their peers in those stats but just numbers vs numbers doesn't prove anything except we're in an era catered to the passing game.

Yea I think 2 or 3 guys threw for over 5000 yards on 2013. It happened like 3 or 4 times ever before that
Link to comment
Share on other sites

The most simple way to this whole thing: NO, Cam is not as good as Peyton.

Move yourself and your stats along.

I'm a Vol who bleeds Orange had have zero doubt you will turn that statement around in a decade. Cam already has a Heistman (as they say in TN) and crystal football in one year which Peyton didn't do in 4. Cam's father wasn't an NFL QB and Cam didn't play big time college football for 4 years. With an embarrassing lack of weapons and protection, Cam's first four years of NFL football are just the tip folks.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


  • PMH4OWPW7JD2TDGWZKTOYL2T3E.jpg

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • You are right--it was DC.  I remember talking to him at Belk in Albemarle one day--the Panthers were on a bye and they were (at the time) a disapointing 4-4.  I mentioned that the record was disappointing and he seemed to get a bit annoyed.  He dId not say anything.  I trying to suggest that we will get better, but I think he was pretty upset about it.  No hard feelings, but the man was simply trying to shop with his wife and this annoying jerk starts making comments about his job---I get it.  I apologized, telling him that I was trying to be supportive and not critical--he did not think it was a big deal.  I'd see him at events from time to time-he'd wave or say hi, but it was awkward for me.  Figured I would say something stupid.  Jordan was pretty popular--nothing like she seems to be now--she is holding her own in a man's world...proud of her.
    • Like we have had the last 3 years.
    • In May of 2026, it looks like a challenging schedule...and it probably is.  I rarely listen to the "strength of schedule" conversations that light up social media this time of year. Each year teams improve and decline. I think there's chunks of the year we need to take care of business and the week 5 bye is not desired.  I do think if we don't hit the bye week at 3-1, it's going to be a major uphill battle given the schedule in front of us. This season falls on three people, regardless of schedule strength: Canales, Bryce, Evero.  Canales: Finally can truly coach all aspects of the team and not focus with gameday prep for OC duties anymore. He drives the bus and needs to get these guys in position to win each week. There's no way vets come in and put it on the line every week to watch our QB sh!t the bed (See: SF game last year). Bryce: Despite everyone's obsession with thinking Bryce is a guaranteed extension, I think this year will truly be his "prove it" year. If he comes out the way he has the past three years, I really don't see how vets and coaches can continue to put him under center long-term. He might play out that fifth year as the starter, but I think next offseason his long-term replacement is found. I also think there's no excuses with the weapons and commitment we've made on offense to insulate him with every possible weapon.  Evero: Best personnel he's had since he's been here...no excuses. Figure out how to blitz effectively. Figure out how to use CBs whose strengths are press/man. Figure out how to utilize a talented front-7 to get the hell of the field. Outside of FS and maybe....maybe ILB, there are few weaknesses on this unit. 
×
×
  • Create New...