Jump to content
  • Welcome!

    Register and log in easily with Twitter or Google accounts!

    Or simply create a new Huddle account. 

    Members receive fewer ads , access our dark theme, and the ability to join the discussion!

     

Grill Bill: Bill says enjoy the ride


Jeremy Igo

Recommended Posts

6 minutes ago, Bartin said:

You can’t really compare the two situations. Brady had just gone 16-0 and led the greatest offense of all time. If this situation was happening in 2016 we would not be treating it the same way we are now because Cam would have been coming off an MVP 15-1 year.

Correct. You can't take that context out of the equation.

The most recent evaluations that we have on Newton would fall under the category of "good, but limited". He performed well through the first eight games last year but it was still pretty obvious that something was wrong. This preseason, it didn't even get that far. Now there's concern about him possibly being fragile.

Yeah, I know. "He's Superman". Except he isn't.

He may be an athletic freak, but athletic freaks are still human.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

59 minutes ago, Mr. Scot said:

Joe Montana, Peyton Manning, Emmitt Smith, Brett Favre and many others all wound up being let go from the teams they were iconically tied to.

It may or may not happen to Cam Newton, but believing that it's totally impossible is incorrect.

Montana was out for 2 full seasons with Young playing at literally an MVP level in his stead.  Manning injury sidelined him for a whole season and they had can't miss prospect Luck waiting in the draft.  Farve "retired" with Rodgers sitting behind him. Cowboys were rebuilding.

10 minutes ago, ItsJustMe said:

I mean he’s right.  When Brady went down with an injury and Cassel came in and went ham on defenses and carrried the team, you didn’t hear about any debates from their fan base about who they would want to keep playing...

On the flip side the Brees and Brady comparisons really don't apply either because, as unfair as it may be to an individual player on a a team playing 50+ people, the teams had significant success with them before the injury (NFC Championship Game, Super Bowl Appearance respectively).

Yes there is the playing through injury aspect which is why we're bombarded with "100% healthy Cam".

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yet another thread about it will certainly settle this discussion once and for all. :eyeroll:

Those who talk about "player only" fans and "emotional attachments" seem to want to drag this discussion out as much as anyone else. The above the fray commentary is laughable.

To stop making threads about it would be a start. But then you would actually have to address the trolls that keep initiating this topic.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 minutes ago, Untouchable said:

Montana was out for 2 full seasons with Young playing at literally an MVP level in his stead.  Manning injury sidelined him for a whole season and they had can't miss prospect Luck waiting in the draft.  Farve "retired" with Rodgers sitting behind him. Cowboys were rebuilding.

And Newton is battling injury with what might be an emerging player behind him.

We don't know how this is going to play out. Acting like any scenario "can't possibly happen" ignores reality.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

11 minutes ago, TheRed said:

Yet another thread about it will certainly settle this discussion once and for all. :eyeroll:

Those who talk about "player only" fans and "emotional attachments" seem to want to drag this discussion out as much as anyone else. The above the fray commentary is laughable.

To stop making threads about it would be a start. But then you would actually have to address the trolls that keep initiating this topic.

Stop responding.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

37 minutes ago, TheRed said:

Yet another thread about it will certainly settle this discussion once and for all. :eyeroll:

Those who talk about "player only" fans and "emotional attachments" seem to want to drag this discussion out as much as anyone else. The above the fray commentary is laughable.

To stop making threads about it would be a start. But then you would actually have to address the trolls that keep initiating this topic.

somebody grab my pearls, gasp, i just have never

Link to comment
Share on other sites

11 minutes ago, Mr. Scot said:

And Newton is battling injury with what might be an emerging player behind him.

We don't know how this is going to play out. Acting like any scenario "can't possibly happen" ignores reality.

So I won't rule anything out but the only 1 in that category is Manning in Indy.  The Colts could have thought Manning will never be the same again and he did have a huge cap hit which have both been brought up as reasons to move on from Newton, but no one should confuse Kyle Allen for Andrew Luck who made what could have been a hard decision a hell of a lot easier.  I like Kyle Allen a lot and didn't want the team to draft a QB because of him but I just don't see this emerging player type argument (at least not yet).

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 minutes ago, Untouchable said:

So I won't rule anything out but the only 1 in that category is Manning in Indy.  The Colts could have thought Manning will never be the same again and he did have a huge cap hit which have both been brought up as reasons to move on from Newton, but no one should confuse Kyle Allen for Andrew Luck who made what could have been a hard decision a hell of a lot easier.  I like Kyle Allen a lot and didn't want the team to draft a QB because of him but I just don't see this emerging player type argument (at least not yet).

I really don’t think anyone, at least anyone sane, is saying we should trade Cam right now. Most of us recognize that Allen still has a lot to prove before we would feel at all comfortable with him as the starter going forward. I wouldn’t trade Cam for two 1sts right now.

We just recognize that the possibility exists where it could be the best move for the franchise to move on from Cam(for money and durability reasons) and have Allen or Grier or someone else at QB. The possibility also exists that Cam comes back 100% and kills it with a quality offensive supporting cast and a monster defense. Only thing that concerns me is winning. Don’t care if it’s Cam or Jimmy Clausen making a comeback at QB.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


  • PMH4OWPW7JD2TDGWZKTOYL2T3E.jpg

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Not following. Each account was started with its own email. Are you saying try to "merge" the accounts via email in a sense? That doesn't seem like it would work. Wouldn't the safest way to be is just wait for the new confirmation email from your original account?
    • Brian Baldinger on NFL Network (per Tim Weaver on Panthers Wire): "I feel like they're building a monster on that side of the ball right now and I think that's how they have to play," Baldinger stated. "They have to play like they can shut teams down this year. I think it's on them to really guide this team right now." https://pantherswire.usatoday.com/story/sports/nfl/panthers/2026/05/22/panthers-nfl-offseason-defense-brian-baldinger/90215555007/   So, do you believe him? Today, May 25, I do believe Baldy without any evidence otherwise. I think it's much more likely for our defense to take another marked leap (right into the top 10) than our, basically, bottom-third offense. In my mind, Lee Hunter is a literal and figurative huge addition up front, and right behind him is perhaps our biggest exclamation point on defense: Devin Lloyd. Lloyd's experience and track record of solid production should be the anchor of our defense that should help lift the floor of the entire unit. No more getting gashed on runs, eh? But, as important as Lloyd will be, the most prolific addition to the defense could be Jaelen Phillips.  In my opinion, whether or not the Panthers can demonstrably show that the defensive squad, and perhaps the team in general, is actually ready to assert itself as a perennial postseason presence lies within its ability to credibly rush passers. Phillips was paid handsomely to produce results. Now I know that most of you are probably thinking that sacks are the key. Moreover, I'm not one that is even going to tell you that his pressures are the key (you know, since Phillips's pressure rate has been highlighted over perhaps pedestrian sack numbers). The key, at least in my mind, will be the marked growth of Nic Scourton and/or Princely Umanmielen. I really do believe that they are the understated X factors that the "success" of our season may depend upon.  I'm not worried about the interior (perhaps over-optimistically so). I'm also not too concerned with our corners, as they are quietly one of the best duos in the league. Sure, the safety position has more question marks, Trevon Moering is an exclamation point, and Nick Scott, though less of an exclamation point, still has plenty of experience. With the infusion of youth, size, length and energy, I can see a good mix that will result in positives from the DBs once Ejiro Evero figures everything out. And, we should all know, a credible pass rush provides the defensive backfield with opportunities to shine, and this is but another reason why I believe that Scourton and maybe Umanmielen will be key to taking up residence in the postseason. On an off note, and as a reminder, if the defense is doing its job effectively maintaining momentum with field position, if not outright laying down the pathway with short fields and such, this should make it easier for Bryce Young and the offense to effect points on the board in terms of TDs. Where the defense goes, the offense will have every opportunity to follow.   
    • Its gonna be loud as hell in Montreal tonight.  But don't make any big turnovers or defensive lapses and I like our chances.
×
×
  • Create New...