Don't let Minshew get away..

[WOW!!]

6 minutes ago, Tr3ach said:

A lot of the greatest qbs of all time had plenty of physical limitations.   Brees and Brady for example.  Neither were mobile.  Neither had especially strong arms.

Brees coming out had a incredible arm coming out of Purdue. AND his arm even after shoulders surgery was way better then Minshew. And Brady while not being a great athlete is 6'5 235 so prototypical QB size..

I know Minshew is your regular guy hero.. But some of you need to watch Brees before 2017 - 2018 and stop trying to make this comparison..

[SizzleBuzz]

2 hours ago, LinvilleGorge said:

Give up, man. Watson got everything he wanted. 

 

He certainly secured a sweet agreement, no doubt...

...let's see if he can live up to the personal demands required to collect on the contract...

...in order to do so he's gonna have to modify his behaviour -- guys with a god-complex + monstrous contract often have trouble doing so...

Edited March 21, 2022 by SizzleBuzz

[KeepPounding5859]

I've been wanting him on this team ever since I say him play the Panthers as a rookie.  If we are committed to building a solid O-line, he can sling it.  Watch this tape.  Notice his demeanor in the pocket under pressure.  Look at his footwork as he throws.  10X better than Darnold.  I would gladly send pick #149 to the Eagles for him.  This would allow snag a top 3 LT, an Edge rusher, or Hamilton at 6.  Worst case you have a solid back up when you give him the original round tender after this season.  I would take him over Baker, over the cost to get Jimmy G, and any of the rookies in this class.

 

 

 

[ForJimmy]

5 minutes ago, SizzleBuzz said:

He certainly secured a sweet agreement, no doubt...

...let's see if he can live up to the personal demands required to collect on the contract...

...in order to do so he's gonna have to modify his behaviour -- guys with a god-complex + monstrous contract often have trouble doing so...

He got traded to a team he approved and he got a huge guaranteed contract. You were wrong about it and can’t handle it. It doesn’t matter if he can “live up” to it because it is guaranteed. 

[ForJimmy]

1 hour ago, WOW!! said:

Your opinion.. Give me the physicality talented player and a good QB developer.. You get a super star..

Get a Minshew you're  constantly trying to cover up his limitations until you get a better player...

A waste of time..

 

So you like Willis? Assuming McAdoo and Ryan can develop him of course… 

[WOW!!]

1 minute ago, ForJimmy said:

So you like Willis? Assuming McAdoo and Ryan can develop him of course… 

Yes.. But if we grab Pickett I won't rage eat about it.. Because he has the size and his arm is good enough even thoe I hate his low ceiling..

[SizzleBuzz]

6 minutes ago, ForJimmy said:

It doesn’t matter if he can “live up” to it because it is guaranteed. 

You're kidding yourself...

..."guaranteed" that contract is rife with morals-clauses and any number of outs should Mr. Whip-It-Out continue to walk outside the boundaries of normal (and legal) human behaviour

[AnnoyedPanther87]

Smh I'll rather start all the way over then to keep bringing in failed after failed attempt at QBs.....If he can't be had for a 5th or higher pick leave him there...

[WOW!!]

I like Wills,  Strong , or Howell..

I would sign Mariota before trading for Minshew..

I'll admit.. I love Love and if compensation is a 4th or lower I would trade for him.. Let him and Sam battle it out.. And depending what happens this season.. Wait till next year and let the new coach pick his QB..

[Jmac]

Give me Minshew, pick the best LT at #6, and one more vet LT in FA (not a JAG), and they have basically rebuild the team in one offseason.... Good job

[ForJimmy]

4 minutes ago, WOW!! said:

I like Wills,  Strong , or Howell..

I would sign Mariota before trading for Minshew..

I'll admit.. I love Love and if compensation is a 4th or lower I would trade for him.. Let him and Sam battle it out.. And depending what happens this season.. Wait till next year and let the new coach pick his QB..

I like Willis, trade down for Howell, and I can live with Pickett.  Mariota really wouldn't be that bad I know some people on here were against it, but he has the size, speed, and has had some success in the league already. 

I really don't have an issue with the Love idea.  If Love can be had for cheap (4th round or so), I could see giving him a shot.  The major red flag to me is how far GB went to keep Rodgers vs rolling with their young talented QB.  Rodgers is getting up there in age and they could have still got a huge return for him.  I mean they let Favre go to roll with Rodgers so they aren't afraid if they are confident in the next guy.  However, Love has talent and if he is terrible you let him walk when his rookie deal is up (one or two years left without picking up the 5th) and take a shot at the next draft class with our new coach.  It would allow up to BPA with our first rounder pick (probably a pass rusher or OT).  

[ForJimmy]

18 minutes ago, SizzleBuzz said:

You're kidding yourself...

..."guaranteed" that contract is rife with morals-clauses and any number of outs should Mr. Whip-It-Out continue to walk outside the boundaries of normal (and legal) human behaviour

He got the contract he wanted for a team he wanted.  You are looking desperate hoping he has some additional conduct issue that in listed in said contract that would negate it.  Unfortunately he is too talented of a player at a premium position and teams are going to look past these off field issues.  He strong armed the Texans owner and it worked despite how much you didn't want it to.  Russ also got traded after requesting a trade.  How does that make you feel?

[w280sax]

41 tds and 12 interceptions in his 22 career starts.  What skill players did he have in those starts with the Jags or the Iggles?

Get him for a 5th and worst case you have a good backup.  Best case, you could have something if put behind a solid line with some weapons.

I really am in favor of this.

[frankw]

3 hours ago, SizzleBuzz said:

Oh it's faaaaaarrr from over, hell the green flag hasn't even been waved yet ...

Guarantee you that contract has a bevy of morals clauses & potential outs built into it --- Mr. Whip-It-Out is gonna have to toe clearly defined line in the sand...

...will be interesting to see if he can control his urges, LOL  

(not to mention the massive  he now has on his back )

 

59 minutes ago, SizzleBuzz said:

You're kidding yourself...

..."guaranteed" that contract is rife with morals-clauses and any number of outs should Mr. Whip-It-Out continue to walk outside the boundaries of normal (and legal) human behaviour