Chris Simms - top 40 QB countdown

[Jackie Lee]

Hm 

20-Jimmy G

19-Wentz

18-Mac Jones

17-Mayfield

Maybe Baker has a better arm than those guys but I dunno. He had other guys lower that I'd swap around a little bit. Pretty much a wash between 30-17 if you give the young guys the advantage of still developing. G/Wentz/Mayfield are what they are at this point

[X-Clown]

12 hours ago, Jackie Lee said:

Hm 

20-Jimmy G

19-Wentz

18-Mac Jones

17-Mayfield

Maybe Baker has a better arm than those guys but I dunno. He had other guys lower that I'd swap around a little bit. Pretty much a wash between 30-17 if you give the young guys the advantage of still developing. G/Wentz/Mayfield are what they are at this point

I'd put Wentz no higher than 26

[Snake]

On 5/19/2022 at 2:52 PM, rayzor said:

I listened to the one he did on sammy. He's got all the tools and athletic ability. It's basically his ability to process and handle pressure. He also talks about him missing the big throws. He doesn't see opportunities and can't capitalize on them when he does see them. We missed out on a lot of points because he couldn't get it done. 

I will never understand teams desire to play a guy who isn't all there up stairs in a football sense. Talent only takes you so far and after that it creates collapses. Even backup quality QBs have decent QB IQs and just avg talent. 

[NAS]

 

[NAS]

Watson not even in the top 10

[ForJimmy]

PJ Walker coming up soon!!!

[rmoneyg35]

I think Cousins should be a little higher and if Watson plays all year then he should be too. I don’t see how Watson can be 13 and baker is 17. If you are going by statistics then baker probably won’t even be top 30 if Watson plays.

[Basbear]

1 hour ago, rmoneyg35 said:

I think Cousins should be a little higher and if Watson plays all year then he should be too. I don’t see how Watson can be 13 and baker is 17. If you are going by statistics then baker probably won’t even be top 30 if Watson plays.

I think sims is making the list as such to get attention and discussion ramped up, its working. 

I may have heard it from him or someone similar- watch for #1....and dont be shocked if its Josh Allen. 

[NAS]

3 minutes ago, Basbear said:

I think sims is making the list as such to get attention and discussion ramped up, its working. 

I may have heard it from him or someone similar- watch for #1....and dont be shocked if its Josh Allen. 

And it should be Josh Allen then Justin Herbert. Mahomes is a bit overrated 

[Basbear]

1 minute ago, NAS said:

And it should be Josh Allen then Justin Herbert. Mahomes is a bit overrated 

Top three can have many different ranks and each would have good points. Since the video game MVP season the league-wide defenses have caught up to Mahomes......and he signed that half billion deal too. I dont know if Justin Herbert is 2, 3, or even 1......I do know if there was a league wide draft and all current players are available, I would no question take Herbert 1st overall. He is about the only recent QB in which I watched and was legit amazed/impressed. 

[NAS]

3 minutes ago, Basbear said:

Top three can have many different ranks and each would have good points. Since the video game MVP season the league-wide defenses have caught up to Mahomes......and he signed that half billion deal too. I dont know if Justin Herbert is 2, 3, or even 1......I do know if there was a league wide draft and all current players are available, I would no question take Herbert 1st overall. He is about the only recent QB in which I watched and was legit amazed/impressed. 

He is further along than Josh Allen was at this point. I wish we traded up to get him two years ago.

[Basbear]

14 minutes ago, NAS said:

He is further along than Josh Allen was at this point. I wish we traded up to get him two years ago.

The saving grace my friend, is that more than likely if Herbert is a panther, Marty Herniay would still be the GM. Im about 96.8% sure.....thats all I tell myself to keep form going crazy about thinking Herbert as a panther.

 

I would be TALKING ALL SORT OF SMACK if herbert was QBing here, 10x the amount I did during the Cam years. Herbert is just like Burrow, even if your OL is trash, they STILL get the W....will the whole team to victory, fug do I miss that. 

Like I tell my indy friend, you dont get to complain for the next 50 years. Colts had Peyton and Luck back2back, most teams havnt had one close to the talent.....poor bears fans.

Edited June 7, 2022 by Basbear

[NAS]

[ForJimmy]

Who is left? Brady, Rodgers, Mahomes, Allen, Herbert, Russ, Stafford, and I am missing one?  PJ or Corral?