Who has been the best post-Cam Panthers QB?

[Bear Hands]

Why are so many picking Heinicke? He played like one end of year game for us.  He's proving to be good NOW, but that doesn't compute with el questione. 

It's Allen & Bridgwater.  Bridgewater was a dull manager who was the most risk-averse, non-aggressive QB I've ever seen.  Allen had a hot streak and teased potential before settling into his current iteration.

[Mr. Scot]

52 minutes ago, Bear Hands said:

Why are so many picking Heinicke? He played like one end of year game for us.  He's proving to be good NOW, but that doesn't compute with el question.

Depends on how you look at the question.

If I were to ask myself, which of this bunch would I most trust to lead the team right now, the answer would probably be Heinicke.

Truth be told, they all come with qualifiers. For example, if you wanted to look at what quarterback had the best performance, I'd actually say it was Sam Darnold...if you only counted his first four games.

[CRA]

Just now, Mr. Scot said:

Depends on how you look at the question.

If I were to ask myself, which of this bunch would I most trust to lead the team right now, the answer would probably be Heinicke.

Truth be told, they all come with qualifiers. For example, if you wanted to look at what quarterback had the best performance, I'd actually say it was Sam Darnold...if you only counted his first four games.

I take the question as who the best for the Carolina Panthers.  Heinicke had 1 TD in a Carolina uniform.  So he doesn't register for me. But I agree, I'd most like to have him on the roster today based on what we have seen overall from the QBs in the NFL. 

So Heinicke is #1 on one way of looking at it and at the bottom the other way. 

[Mr. Scot]

23 minutes ago, CRA said:

I take the question as who the best for the Carolina Panthers. 

And that's probably in fitting with the spirit of the question.

Problem is everybody was so bad you have to do at least some level of mental gymnastics call anybody "best".

[KSpan]

19 hours ago, year of the snitch said:

where is all of this love for Teddy coming from? He was ass and never could win games.

I don't think pocking Teddy as the least-worst QB since 2017 Cam is the same as 'love'. I can't stand the guy as a player but while he is a milquetoast AB, the team generally did not look as utterly terrible with him as with others. They still sucked, just maybe not as much.

[Wundrbread33]

22 hours ago, saX man said:

Records:

PJ Walker 4-3

Kyle Allen 7-10

Sam Darnold 5-7

Bridgewater 4-11

Baker 1-5

Heinecke 0-1

Will Grier 0-2

 

Team game. 
 

Remember the “Teddy’s record in Minnesota and 5-0 with the Saints” line of thinking?

 

Wins is a team stat, not a QB stat.

[saX man]

18 minutes ago, Wundrbread33 said:

Team game. 
 

Remember the “Teddy’s record in Minnesota and 5-0 with the Saints” line of thinking?

 

Wins is a team stat, not a QB stat.

I did nothing other than list their records.  Take it for what you want.