Mike Kaye explains DJ Johnson pick

[CRA]

The 3rd round pick defense is the definition of just blind defense of the home team.  We would knock any other team for the reach given the the better options/football players available . 

if you can’t knock the pick then you basically are arguing no pick by any team should be criticized . 

 

[Luciu5]

I don't like the move. If you are going to trade up, do it for someone you really really want or bpa. This feels very out of character for Fitt. I'm guessing he was the last guy at the position on their board and they said f it. All in all I don't care, but seems like a dumb move.

[mrcompletely11]

3 minutes ago, CRA said:

The 3rd round pick defense is the definition of just blind defense of the home team.  We would knock any other team for the reach given the the better options/football players available . 

if you can’t knock the pick then you basically are arguing no pick by any team should be criticized . 

 

Its not just the pick its the giving up a 4rth for it

[Mr. Scot]

2 minutes ago, CRA said:

The 3rd round pick defense is the definition of just blind defense of the home team.  We would knock any other team for the reach given the the better options/football players available . 

if you can’t knock the pick then you basically are arguing no pick by any team should be criticized . 

You can fairly criticize any pick we've made. Hell, if they turn out bad, you probably look smart for doing so.

Of course it's also true that if they play well you might wind up looking like a dumbsh-t

[Bear Hands]

My only questioning is what sets DJ apart from Isaiah McGuire, Hampton, or KJ Henry at EDGE. They must see something specific in him that set him apart to trade up for.  

 

 

[mrcompletely11]

1 minute ago, Luciu5 said:

I don't like the move. If you are going to trade up, do it for someone you really really want or bpa. This feels very out of character for Fitt. I'm guessing he was the last guy at the position on their board and they said f it. All in all I don't care, but seems like a dumb move.

I mean do they really think this dude is going to be a better building block for your team then Darnall washington?  It really doesnt make a lick of sense

[Mother Grabber]

14 minutes ago, mrcompletely11 said:

wasted draft capital

a 24 year old project that hasnt produced poo and is only being drafted based on his combine results

6 sacks and 8.5 TFL in 10 starts at OLB seems like some tasty production to me.

[Swaggasaurus]

BJ and DJ had the exact same stat lines last year. Motherfugers acting like Mingo over BJ was a huge loss. SAME Stats as the colossal mistake DJ Johnson. Gtfo with that poo. Y’all motherfugers look at Walterfootball and decide who is good and who ain’t.

[mrcompletely11]

1 minute ago, Mr. Scot said:

You can fairly criticize any pick we've made. Hell, if they turn out bad, you probably look smart for doing so.

Of course it's also true that if they play well you might wind up looking like a dumbsh-t

I love, absolutely love the mingo pick but goddamn that shouldnt send fitt and co into a damn death spiral of desperation in trying to get a DE.   Just take the lump and move on down the road. 

[Mr. Scot]

1 minute ago, mrcompletely11 said:

I love, absolutely love the mingo pick but goddamn that shouldnt send fitt and co into a damn death spiral of desperation in trying to get a DE.   Just take the lump and move on down the road. 

I'm reminded of a recent discussion about the value of early draft grades...

[CRA]

4 minutes ago, Mr. Scot said:

You can fairly criticize any pick we've made. Hell, if they turn out bad, you probably look smart for doing so.

Of course it's also true that if they play well you might wind up looking like a dumbsh-t

lol if you play simple odds and math the genius move is to criticize every pick that isn’t a first rounder and you basically are going to generally be right the overwhelming majority of the time lol.    And that’s without even looking at who we pick at any point.  

 

[mrcompletely11]

1 minute ago, Mr. Scot said:

I'm reminded of a recent discussion about the value of early draft grades...

its a 3rd and a 4rth for a 24 year old "project".  Draft grade or not that looks fuging stupid on paper

[Luciu5]

3 minutes ago, mrcompletely11 said:

I love, absolutely love the mingo pick but goddamn that shouldnt send fitt and co into a damn death spiral of desperation in trying to get a DE.   Just take the lump and move on down the road. 

This I agree with every word. Was not getting a a random EDGE in this draft really the end of the world? I just don't think it was necessary to panic.

[mrcompletely11]

1 minute ago, CRA said:

lol if you play simple odds and math the genius move is to criticize every pick that isn’t a first rounder and you basically are going to generally be right the overwhelming majority of the time lol.    And that’s without even looking at who we pick at any point.  

 

I like the bryce pick, hes the best qb we have had in half a decade

I love the mingo pick for numerous reasons

I despise the DJ pick for numerous reasons