Clausen vs Luck vs Young... who would you want??

[theyhateme45]

At this rate all three could be possibilities for next season, some more than others. With Young pouting and walking out on his team he seems to be on his way out of Tennessee. If they do waive him, we will have first shot at him and I'm not sure the Panthers will pass on him seeing as we are depleted at the position right now.

So as a panther fan would you rather

A) Let Jimmy Develop go into next season with him as a starter and draft another position with our early 1st round pick (O-line, D-line, WR, CB ect... my pick would be AJ Green)

Draft Andrew luck... build around him and be set at QB for the future.

C) Bring in VY, draft a top talent and build around him, while Jimmy still has a shot to regain the starting position.

Personally my choice would be B.... Andrew Luck is a rare talent and in a qb driven league he could eventually help in taking us back to a superbowl and being ontop. I honestly believe Luck is almost a safe a bet as Peyton Manning was coming out of college.

[CharlotteBeer.com]

I don't see Tennessee letting Young go for nothing. Even if they did, Fox and Fisher are very alike in that they will not tolerate the sort of behavior exhibited by Young over the last couple of years.

I like Young and would love to have him here (if he could stay out of trouble), but I just don't see it happening.

I'm sort of torn on the whole draft Luck or develop Clausen thing, especially since I think it's very hard to evaluate Clausen with two rookie receivers and a porous offensive line. I guess the easy answer is to wait and see who our next coach is, what sort of offense the team will run, and go from there.

[Jpjr]

"The mob is fickle"

Just curious, are most Andrew Luck fans also Matt Moore fans... until they weren't?

[theyhateme45]

Sorry I left off an option...

For those who want, I guess

Resign Matt Moore and go with him as the starter could be a write in candidate....

I forgot about the option, though I'm not a fan of it, it is an option for the team.

[Happy Panther]

We could trade our 2nd round pick for Vince Young

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAAAA!!!!!!!

[Jhyler12]

None of the above...

[chknwing]

Vince Young? No, No, No and a thousand times more No.

[rayzor]

regardless of what we do, it's pretty clear that we need to have a vet...a real vet...to come in and carry the clipboard for a couple years. i don't care about having clausen/luck sit on the bench, imo, he needs to get out there and play. he just needs to have someone with a lot of playing experience on the sidelines.

pennington/hasslebeck/bulger/mccown would be my choices, probably in that order.

[rayzor]

Vince Young? No, No, No and a thousand times more No.

ditto that. dude's a headcase. granted he's playing for one of the most overrated HCs out there who should have been fired a long time ago, but still...i just get a kerry collins vibe from him.

[CharlotteBeer.com]

regardless of what we do, it's pretty clear that we need to have a vet...a real vet...to come in and carry the clipboard for a couple years. i don't care about having clausen/luck sit on the bench, imo, he needs to get out there and play. he just needs to have someone with a lot of playing experience on the sidelines.

pennington/hasslebeck/bulger/mccown would be my choices, probably in that order.

What about Delhomme? Could be intriguing under a coach that wouldn't be tempted to start him.

[iamcline]

lol @ Vince Young

[SOJA]

Pennington is said to have a suffered a career ending injury so I doubt his noodliness arm is an option

[Snake]

Its hard to pass on Luck if we get the 1st overall pick. Really there are only two major needs I see on this team. A QB and a DT and DT and there really are not lights out DT prospects so Luck it is.

[Jangler]

Cowher would love to have Young.