was the armanti edwards trade the worst in franchise history?

[Grammer]

most definitely

you do NOT trade draft picks with the patriots, they're whole success is built on picking on the retard kids in april

[Kurb]

not until he is cut

when he is cut with no production then he is worst ever

[Dpantherman]

damnit wheres my pie?!

[R0CKnR0LLA]

hmmm lets trade the 33rd pick for an 89th pick to take a late round prospect thats a huge risk converting positions out of a 1-AA school

good god why does hurney still have a job

[Davidson Deac II]

Way, way, way, way to early to tell how Edwards works out.

And fwiw, it would be physically impossible for the Edwards trade to be worse than the Sean Gilbert trade, when we gave up two first round draft picks to get a average and often injured defensive lineman.

[Panthercougar68]

not until he is cut

when he is cut with no production then he is worst ever

Agreed

but I also think you can argue that it's the worst pick based on what it took to get him and the situation that that pick would be highly valuable to us now if we had it. We could have easily gotten a stud guard with this pick.

[The NFL Shield At Midfield]

Sean fuging Gilbert

[koolkatluke]

most definitely

you do NOT trade draft picks with the patriots, they're whole success is built on picking on the retard kids in april

How long have U been a panther fan???

Do you not remeber the Sean Gilbert trade too the redskin?

That was the worst trade AE trade doesn't even come close. Ask a real panther fan about that trade.

[Davidson Deac II]

not until he is cut

when he is cut with no production then he is worst ever

Still wouldn't be worse than the Gilbert trade.

[Baschski]

Do you people honestly expect Marty Hurney to be able to psychically predict our draft position each year? As if he knew we would have the first pick in the draft.

Also, how about we let Armanti play a season with a coach who doesn't hate him before we f*cking pass judgment on him. The kid could turn out to be a player. Fox never gave him a chance. Project doesn't mean failure. It means they can be good with development and coaching. Armanti received neither this year.

[Cyclonus]

If it wasn't for the Herschel Walker trade, I would say it's the worst of all time.

[Stroupe-a-loop]

Yeah, Sean Gilbert was way worse. To the extent that they don't acknowledge the move on the official team's trade log on panthers.com. As others have said, it's not even close. People are way overacting the the Armanti thing. Stupid? Yes. Very Stupid? Probably. But it's not really going to destroy the franchise or anything.

[CarolinaPanthers8789]

It wouldn't have been so bad if he was actually activated for more than 2 games this season.

[OnlyPantherFaninMaine]

Could be, but I'll wait to pass judgment until he's played out his rookie contract. Let's get an offensive minded coach that can utilize AE and allow the kid to see the damn field to start.