Spot on Dtan's first annual QB rankings

[GritsRgreat]

what is wrong with #8?

He's ranked no. freakin 8.

[Guest Spot On Dtan]

Folks, I appreciate you input and all.

But I have to say....

These rankings are "Spot On."

[Chimera]

spot on your chin

[blackcatgrowl]

The day Michael Vick is legitimately put higher up on a QB list than Tom Brady or Peyton Manning, is the day dog fighting becomes an Olympic Sport.

And WTF do you mean by "The White MV7"? Aaron Rogers is 10x better of a passer than Michael Vick, and not nearly as mobile.

*sniff* I think I smell something *sniff*

:troll:

[Peppers90 NC]

i've seen worse lisps.

[Grammer]

1. Brady

2. Manning

3. Rodgers

4. Brees

5. Rivers

6. Vick

You could swap 6 and 5

[Varking]

We need to stop ranking Rivers so highly if they continue to suck in the playoffs and post mediocre records during the regular season.

Same thing with Schaub and Romo. Do we just say " Hey, they put up numbers so that makes them good"? How far has Dallas made it despite being loaded with talent with Tony Romo? How many playoff appearances has Houston earned under Schaub?

Also on Vick being number one... You don't push a guy to the top of the class when he just had his first nice year as a passer in his career. He also only played 12 games last year.

[Mother Grabber]

What the hell is Ben doing at #6?

[panthers55]

Explain to me how this is "trolling."

I posted my opinion on a message board.

And, even though I am from a rival team,

I ranked your QB as the top rookie.

And if this were your only thread it would be fine. But you got kicked off the Falcons board for being argumentative and you come here where the rules are more relaxed to argue and create conflict. That is what trolls do. They come on opposing team's message boards to argue and create controversy. I am fine with anyone coming on here and expressing their opinion as it is a free country. But it still makes you a troll.

[panthers55]

I don't think you can put Vick at the top of any list until he at least wins a Super Bowl or carries his team on his back in the playoffs. He had one very good season in his career and people annoint him as the best QB. Seriously???

Even if Philly wins it all this year, it will be more about who they added on defense than it will be about Vick. Lets see how he does when the NFC East gameplans for him this year. It reminds me of what he did in Atlanta his first few years until teams in the division gameplanned for him and put in spies, etc. His effectiveness went down appreciably.

That list's validity is very spotty indeed.

[Johnny Rockets]

I don't think you can put Vick at the top of any list until he at least wins a Super Bowl or carries his team on his back in the playoffs. He had one very good season in his career and people annoint him as the best QB. Seriously???

Even if Philly wins it all this year, it will be more about who they added on defense than it will be about Vick. Lets see how he does when the NFC East gameplans for him this year. It reminds me of what he did in Atlanta his first few years until teams in the division gameplanned for him and put in spies, etc. His effectiveness went down appreciably.

That list's validity is very spotty indeed.

Even with an improved offensive line I have my concerns with Vick duplicating last year. His first half was much better than his second half last year and what you are saying above may have had a big part in that. No way Vick is #1 QB in the league. He would have to do what he did last year again to even be considered in a top 5 conversation.

[Peppers90 NC]

You want spot on? Dan became a Falcons fan because of Vick. He is still a Vick fan and barely a Falcons fan. He is our version of a dumbed down TRD, in his regards to Ryan. Matt Ryan should is a top 15 QB.

[armistice]

I got as far as the first Qb....and realized it wasn't spot on

+1

[thefuzz]

Manning

Rivers

Rodgers

Brady

Brees