Funny Bengals forum thread on Dalton and Cam

[chef17]

it doesn't from a team perspective....just matters the team gets production.

you want to compare QB play....then yeah, how he gets them matters.

Sam Bradford has more completions than any rookie in NFL history.....he did that checking down and playing safe. You can get production from an offense with a QB not making big throws.

You watch Cam for 4 weeks straight and Dalton for 4 weeks straight.....and there is no comparing what they do as QBs.......or are asked to do. Dalton doesn't make the throws Cam is asked to make as often......Dalton also flat out can't make some Cam is asked to make. Cam also does the work Dalton's supporting cast provides on his own......he has more 3rd down pickups than any RB in the NFL.

I was never comparing QB play. Multiple people have said "all he does is lob it up to Green". I listed their stats and proved otherwise.

[CRA]

No Dalton is asked to win games.

no. Rookies like Ryan, Sanchez, Dalton aren't asked to do or be what Cam/Peyton have been asked. Cam/Peyton were asked to be THE team. The rest were asked to play roles.

[PantherAZ]

Dalton lovers can bring up all the stats, facts, and records they want. It is all meaningless. Dalton is a ginger, threfore he has no soul. Black men are better than gingers. End of story.

[MHS831]

They got a bargain in Dalton. He is a good rookie QB and is outplaying first round picks. But he is no Cam. Wait until Cam gets a D behind him. Wait until we do not have a backup center at RG and an undrafted rookie at RT. Wait until Gettis returns. Wait until Cam puts an entire season behind him like his last 5 games.

Cincy got a good one. I wanted us to take Dareus in the first and Dalton in the second--oh yeah. Bet Cincy doesn't have an Armanti Edwards!! (Who is Cribbs?) Scratch the last comment.

[kman72]

i think its funny they had to kick panther or any other fan besides "bungle" fans out because no one else is stupid enough to think dalton is better than cam. not sayn dalton is bad but never more than a game manager in my opinion.

[SCP]

Bengals fans live in Ohio so by default they fail at everything.

[teeray]

Dalton wins because he played Jax, Indy, Cleveland x2, Denver, Buffalo, St. Louis, Seattle, and Arizona

Most of the NFL would win 8 or 9 games when 66% of their schedule are these guys.

The only good teams CIN have played are SF, Pitt x2, and Baltimore.

If only Cam had that schedule instead of GB, Chicago (with Cutler), Atl x2, New Orleans, Houston, and Detroit he would be more of a “winner”.

[chef17]

Dalton wins because he played Jax, Indy, Cleveland x2, Denver, Buffalo, St. Louis, Seattle, and Arizona

Most of the NFL would win 8 or 9 games when 66% of their schedule are these guys.

The only good teams CIN have played are SF, Pitt x2, and Baltimore.

If only Cam had that schedule instead of GB, Chicago (with Cutler), Atl x2, New Orleans, Houston, and Detroit he would be more of a “winner”.

To be fair Arizona did beat us :p

[The NFL Shield At Midfield]

To be fair Arizona did beat us :p

Not with John Skelton

[Gazi]

I see they started crying and Panthers fans aren't allowed to post in there. It's like a circle jerk now with no one to disagree with them. Homers

[Russian Bear]

Id stop being a fan if the carolina qb was a readhead and im obsessed with the panthers

[Russian Bear]

I almost felt the same about clausen. I wanted to cry when we picked him.