Weinke or Carr?

[mantal]

Cmon now. I agree this is a stupid thread but the singlemost stupid thread ever? You have been here long enough to have seen some hall of famers.

I know, but mediocrity doesn't sell...

[X-Clown]

Cmon now. I agree this is a stupid thread but the singlemost stupid thread ever? You have been here long enough to have seen some hall of famers.

Like the 10 + pagers that suggested that both of these guys should start over Jake

[Brokenbad]

My response is why would I even respond to this? This is the singlemost stupid thread I've seen here and that's saying a lot. And there is actually serious discussion here? Fuggin' offseason...

Perhaps it is stupid....BUT you responded :rofl:

[mantal]

Perhaps it is stupid....BUT you responded :rofl:

Yeah, I knew I'd get that response at the time I made it...

[Baschski]

David Carr. Who remembers that sweet somersault/dive thing he did for the first down? That was pretty cool, even if all he did after that was suck.

[Squirrel]

Like the 10 + pagers that suggested that both of these guys should start over Jake

Hey! That was some darn good entertainment!

I should become a defense lawyer, I will argue the sky is purple just for the sake of arguing.

[outlaw4]

Would the choice really matter? We'd lose the game either way and look bad doing it. The only difference would be looking at a balding guy or a guy wearing gloves under center.

[Squirrel]

Would the choice really matter? We'd lose the game either way and look bad doing it. The only difference would be looking at a balding guy or a guy wearing gloves under center.

But we would have over 300 yard passing with Weinke.

[WolfPack]

Weinke, hands down

[outlaw4]

But we would have over 300 yard passing with Weinke.

Yeah but the somersault, THE SOMERSAULT!!! :willy_nilly:

[ATTACH]31006[/ATTACH]

[Sandy Claws]

My response is why would I even respond to this? This is the singlemost stupid thread I've seen here and that's saying a lot.

And yet, after identifiying it as the singlemost stupid thread you've seen here and questioning why you would respond, you chose to respond. I'll repeat your question, Why did you?

[Kettle]

pie

[nosuchthingasapanther]

Yeah but the somersault, THE SOMERSAULT!!! :willy_nilly:

[ATTACH]31006[/ATTACH]

yeah, but he screwed that up by putting the ball on the ground without going down. if it wasn't for everyone being stunned by his gynastics, all the defense had to do was pick the ball up since it was technically a fumble.

my choice is for weinke.

i've always been under the impression that he was just cursed, and not necessarily a bad QB.

[Fireball77]

IMO Weinke is proof that having good physical skills means nothing without the rest of the package.