Weinke or Carr?

[Brokenbad]

If you had to make a decision to start one or the other for the Panthers, who would it be? Weinke has the longest losing streak for a starting QB in NFL history. Carr holds several records for being sacked. At least they both hold records......

[VGcollector]

I'd choose Weinke at least he threw for 400 yards in a game plus i think the team liked him more.

[scpanther22]

carr

[Peppa Jack Supreme]

Chris did a much better job of handing the ball off. Hell, there were plays when they would snap it right to DeAngelo. They never did that with Carr. Id take my chances with Chris.

[SCP]

I literally hate David Carr because of his gloves. So I can't participate in your survey because of my bias.

[joemac]

Start Weinke!!!!!!

[panthers55]

Seriously, what kind of choice is that??

Why not ask me whether I would rather shove a 10 inch spike up my nose into the soft tissue of my brain, or smash my balls with a hammer one at a time.

I would rather have williams run the ball on every down than have Weinke or Carr be my quarterback. I guess Henning and I agree about one thing.

[Oldschool Leroy]

I liked Weinke and I am sorry it did not work out for him.

[Brokenbad]

Seriously, what kind of choice is that??

Why not ask me whether I would rather shove a 10 inch spike up my nose into the soft tissue of my brain, or smash my balls with a hammer one at a time.

I would rather have williams run the ball on every down than have Weinke or Carr be my quarterback. I guess Henning and I agree about one thing.

I agree, but I always wondered who the fans would pick if they had to go with one. Personally if there was no more QB's left on the roster, I would just run the wildcat the whole game.

[rayzor]

what do you like more? getting kicked in the balls or kidneys?

answer: neither.

[John Fox]

If you had to make a decision to have one of these diseases , what would it be? Aids has killed more people, but you can get anal, testicle, breast, brain cancer, and much more.

[d-run]

I would pick Wienke. Does anyone remember the game that Jake had to come out and Weinke came in and led us to a win. I think it was against Minn. I don't remember the details of the game, but I remember making peace with him after that game.

[1789Cardiac Cats9020]

Neither. I'd rather die

[panthers55]

I would pick Wienke. Does anyone remember the game that Jake had to come out and Weinke came in and led us to a win. I think it was against Minn. I don't remember the details of the game, but I remember making peace with him after that game.

It was Detroit in 2005. Last time he did anything great for the Panthers. It made the organization think he was more than he was. It kept us from replacing him sooner.