Official Carolina Huddle Panthers MVP Poll

[OriginalPantherDan]

It's gotta be Cam. Listen...Luke makes this defense great, but Cam has won a few games almost single-handedly when the offense disappeared (I'm looking at you, Shula). Without him, we don't make the playoffs, let alone the NFCS crown.

[TheRed]

The trolls are already coming out I see...

[Panthro]

I came to vote for a Huddle MVP.

 

Sorry Alice....you'll just have to wait

[TheRed]

Cam had a good year and the theory is if we surround him with better talent he will become elite. But we don't know if this will happen. I hope it will.

 

We already tested the theory with Luke and he became elite. Defense made us 12-4 this year

 

I suppose it's Cam Newton's fault that he had exactly 0 (yes that's zero) starters from the draft on offense playing along side him this season since he got here in 2011. We have invested heavily in defense, they certainly should be helping to carry the team at this point.

[Panthro]

Thomas Davis

[PhillyB]

take any player besides cam off this team and replace them with a JAG and we still win 10-12 football games.

 

take cam off this team and replace him with a JAG and we're the 2010 panthers all over again.

 

 

[Happy Panther]

I suppose it's Cam Newton's fault that he had exactly 0 (yes that's zero) starters from the draft on offense playing along side him this season since he got here in 2011. 

 

Not sure how you derived that from my post

[PantherPride5]

Superman hands down.

[MichaelNewtonII]

Cam

Sent from my SGH-T399 using CarolinaHuddle mobile app

[TheRed]

Not sure how you derived that from my post

 

You said you were unsure if putting talent around Cam will lead to be him becoming "elite". Yet in the same breath speak of Luke already being elite due to being surrounded by substantial talent. I just don't get that. Considering all that our quarterback has done so far with what he has been given to work with, I don't think there is any question that given the proper supporting cast, the sky is the limit.

[Happy Panther]

 I don't think there is any question that given the proper supporting cast, the sky is the limit.

 

Could be but that is an assumption. We will only know when it happens.

 

Plenty of other potential elites never got there

[Jackofalltrades]

I have to go with Luke as the leader of the best D in the league and his stats. Cam is a close second but the offensive struggles and some of his really bad plays stick out.

[Peppers90 NC]

Replace Cam with a non mobile QB (not named Brady or Manning) and this team would have won 4 games.

yea but Cam is on the team and that's what the offense is based from, even with Chud as OC or anyone who obtains the position in the future.  shula would never have even been considered if he didnt have such a good rapport with Cam

[TheRed]

Could be but that is an assumption. We will only know when it happens.

 

Plenty of other potential elites never got there

 

Quite frankly I don't care if he is ever considered "elite" by some snob behind a computer or a teleprompter, and I'm sure he would tell you the same thing. It's all about winning, no matter how you accomplish it, that's what matters. This offseason is crucial to his continued development.