All Activity

He is literally good at nothing. Fun fact, per NFL Next Gen Stats he had the third highest catch percentage for a WR among qualifying players in 2024 and was 5th in 2023. You are starting to sound like a JT O'Sullivan sock account, brother. Questioning AT's hands is a pretty odd hill to die on.

2 firsts, 2 seconds, plus DJ Moore (top 15 WR in the NFL) for a small and slight framed QB who can't process the line, has happy feet, and at best and adequate arm... That's way worse than the Gilbert trade and it's not even close. It's at least the worst Panthers trade by far.

Not sure how you can argue Gilbert being worse? It was bad but this one takes the top spot.

I got pooed for hating the trade up in the first place and then again when I thought Stroud should have been the pick.

Trading the best WR in many years for a bust QB will go down as one of the biggest blunders ever sadly.

Bosa with the FF loss of 15

If he got hands on the ball it was caught. It was that simple with him.

Oops killed the drive my bad guys

I didn’t cherry pick anything. I listed the first round picks. Can you find a better record in the 21st century?

Hurney was horrendous. He was great in the first round that's it. Any other round and FA was largely trash. But we were still immensely more competitive with him more consistently than the jabronis we've had in the front office the last few years. That's because when he hit in the first he hit on cornerstone talent. We can't do that. Not even close.

I said that in the lead up to the draft. Said no way you can take him top 5-10. He had happy feet issues at Alabama, he had to play off schedule. Small frame, small height, adequate arm strength, couldn't process at the line well. Just never got how he was considered QB 1 in that draft. I think I had him 4th or 5th.

Walker, Wilson, and Watson were 10x worse. It's not even the worst panther trade, Id say Gilbert has that crown.

Random but something I find interesting: the outlook on Bryce on X/Twitter is a lot more positive than here. A lot of talk about still believing in him and this game wasn’t his fault etc. I wonder why that on here it is more negative and X it’s more positive? Anyway, didn’t mean to derail the thread.

Mark Schlereth or whatever was going off on him on the broadcast for that horrible display of effort. It really encapsulates our team in 1 play. I feel bad for dudes like DB, Chuba, Horn who actually go hard...just asking to get hurt playing with these bums

Bryce is really a dumbass when you hear him talk. Uuhhhhh uhhhhh ummmm

the legend of AT grows! Fun fact - 1 out of every 4 balls thrown to Adam Thielen by Bryce weren’t caught by him. I would assume Bryce having the worst on target % in all the NFL is a key reason and putting folks in bad spots He would have got the XL ball because it was just simple feet though. The Renfrow stuff is just making AT into a myth.

Sunk cost is for moving forward. We’re looking back at who’s the biggest bust. The cost is relevant.

One of two good players on a shat defense doesn't help much.

I’m just trying to not be inflammatory.

Ravens at 175 yards rushing before halftime.

The only take away is that panthers.com was a fluff price? I swear I thought we were Super Bowl contenders per reports!?!?!

204? fify

So you don't have time to do anything but cherry picking but you want me to compile the track record of 32 teams GM's across almost 60 years of NFL history? Seems reasonable. How about I just let you continue to live the delusion that Marty Hurney was a good GM?

They're arguing sunk cost. But you're right. This stink won't wash off for a long time. Best thing we can do is pull the plug for good and soon. These dreams of tanking getting the first pick and backing our way into another generational alpha QB are just that.