I was wrong about Oher

[t96]

51 minutes ago, rodeo said:

Oher should be in consideration for comeback player of the year. Though obviously Berry should win it.

Berry?

[tiger7_88]

20 minutes ago, thomas96 said:

Berry?

KC safety who came back from cancer treatment.

[t96]

Just now, tiger7_88 said:

KC safety who came back from cancer treatment.

Palmer or Peterson would be better bets.

[tiger7_88]

4 minutes ago, thomas96 said:

Palmer or Peterson would be better bets.

I don't know.

I would vote for coming back from chemotherapy treatment for Hodgkins lymphoma over coming back from a torn ACL or suspension for child abuse.

[GRWatcher]

3 minutes ago, thomas96 said:

Palmer or Peterson would be better bets.

Nah. After Stuart Scott & Jimmy V you can't get past beating cancer as the winner for comeback player. I'd be surprised to say the least.

[t96]

Just now, tiger7_88 said:

I don't know.

I would vote for coming back from chemotherapy treatment for Hodgkins lymphoma over coming back from a torn ACL or suspension for child abuse.

The reason for being out is irrelevant. It's how well they've played after being out for an extended period.

[tiger7_88]

1 minute ago, thomas96 said:

The reason for being out is irrelevant. It's how well they've played after being out for an extended period.

I utterly and totally disagree.

The reason you are out determines the EXTENT of your comeback.

AP only had to come back from being a dumbass.  Palmer had to rehab after ACL surgery, sure, but mobility isn't part of his game anyway.

You ever went through chemo?  I haven't.  But I have close friends who have.  Its a stone-cold bitch of a deal.  And then, afterwards, you condition well enough to come back at a Pro Bowl level?  THAT'S a comeback.

[Proudiddy]

Agreed and loved the signing when we made it and i felt like he was going to get back on track here.  Happy to have him...

But, did dude say, "after trudging through *A* year of Byron Bell"?  Lol...  i'm smiling through the tears.

[t96]

1 minute ago, tiger7_88 said:

I utterly and totally disagree.

The reason you are out determines the EXTENT of your comeback.

AP only had to come back from being a dumbass.  Palmer had to rehab after ACL surgery, sure, but mobility isn't part of his game anyway.

You ever went through chemo?  I haven't.  But I have close friends who have.  Its a stone-cold bitch of a deal.  And then, afterwards, you condition well enough to come back at a Pro Bowl level?  THAT'S a comeback.

I'm not saying what I think it should be but what I said it was is what it is. Mike Vick won comeback player of the year after being out for dogfighting, what caused somebody to be out clearly does not matter.

[PantherPhann89]

Welcome to the Blindside....

[SamMills4Life]

I thought we was going to straight up suck. In truth, we wouldn't have won 15 games without him.

[Ivan The Awesome]

4 hours ago, Kuechly59 said:

He's only 28 young for a tackle....

 

Easily 5 more years. 

[MHS831]

Maybe you were right about Oher, wrong about Matsko,  (Today's "deep thought")

[MHS831]

Remmers has fallen on hard times, it would seem.  If we were losing, more of us would take notice.