Jump to content
  • Welcome!

    Register and log in easily with Twitter or Google accounts!

    Or simply create a new Huddle account. 

    Members receive fewer ads , access our dark theme, and the ability to join the discussion!

     

No team will hire Shula after that playcalling and Panthers won't release him after he ran the #1 scoring offense


megadeth078

Recommended Posts

7 minutes ago, fieryprophet said:

And? With Denver mugging the edges we should have been able to attack them up the middle, but Kalil, Turner and even Norwell couldn't generate any push. How many times did Stewart hit a hole and get stopped by arm tackles? He was literally a leap away from breaking one but the o-line couldn't even keep defenders at arm's length.

You didn't even make an attempt at answering my last two questions.  Did you quote me by accident?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

why the absolute fug would you want to get rid of the OC who orchestrated the #1 offense with mediocre receivers? what part of #1 offense in the league is hard to understand? there isn't one better. his offense was #1. jeebus.

This isn't really supposed to be a "Fire Shula" thread.  I just wanted to present two reasons why I think he'll be here for sure next season.  I don't think he'll be getting any calls for head coaching gigs, and of course the Panthers won't be releasing him.  I wanted to know what people thought of him coming back.  Personally, I'm more worried than hopeful.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

37 minutes ago, megadeth078 said:

This isn't really supposed to be a "Fire Shula" thread.  I just wanted to present two reasons why I think he'll be here for sure next season.  I don't think he'll be getting any calls for head coaching gigs, and of course the Panthers won't be releasing him.  I wanted to know what people thought of him coming back.  Personally, I'm more worried than hopeful.  

the Shula and gettleman haters spilled out like roaches after Sunday, hard to tell. :-)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

44 minutes ago, megadeth078 said:

This isn't really supposed to be a "Fire Shula" thread.  I just wanted to present two reasons why I think he'll be here for sure next season.  I don't think he'll be getting any calls for head coaching gigs, and of course the Panthers won't be releasing him.  I wanted to know what people thought of him coming back.  Personally, I'm more worried than hopeful.  

We played the best defense in the league this year and looked bad doing it.  It was just an off day, it happens and it sucks that it was in the Super Bowl but I really don't want to get a new OC in here and start all over with Cam.  Personally I think the offense we run is best suited for Newton...all we need is Benji back, upgrade at RT, have Funchess back with a full year of development and I think we'll be fine

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, carolina-chuck2 said:

STHU!

 

quit blaming Shula. He's not the one overthrowing receivers. Not the one dropping passes. Not the one that couldn't block. Not the one fumbling. 

He should have gotten a HC job. A lot better than some of these fools that got hired. 

Was Shula the one responsible for setting up max pro? Was Shula the one responsible for calling a double pass play? Was Shula responsible for sending Fozzy between the tackles on power runs? Was Shula the one responsible for not game planning Von Miller? Was Shula the one responsible for expecting Mike Remmers to match up with Von Miller and Michael Oher to match up with Ware 1 on 1 when it was 3rd and long?

You have to answer yest to all of these questions because they directly link back to Shula's responsibility. The biggest error is an OC that treats Von Miller like a typical pass rusher on 3rd down instead of at least rubbing him with 1 or 2 receivers. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, fieryprophet said:

Let me surprise people here with a plain reality: Shula's playcalling didn't lose this game. Player execution accounted for far more, such as the dropped passes and fumbles and inability to run or pass block. On a list of grievances Shula is pretty damn low down the list.

Don't buy it, they knew the hand they were dealt. You coordinate accordingly... Didn't happen.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

7 hours ago, PhillyB said:

still not sure how shula is getting the burn for all this. running those plays up the gut is precisely how you negate crashing ends.

"we kept running long developing routes" is a myth and a reflexive holdover from the first half of 2014. we ran a ton of short stuff and just didn't connect on it, or ended up with turnovers at absolutely horrible times.

take away cam's pick (teddy's fault) and tolbert's second fumble and i think we win this game.

I'm trying to understand why he did not call more screens or quick slants to negate that rush. It was obvious from the start that they were stopping the run and he never changed it up.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I suspect the Shula hate has been bubbling under the surface all year when things were going well but just erupted because of the superbowl. Shula called a bad game, but we had the #1 scoring offense for a good reason, and at this point in his career, right at the start of his prime is it really wise having Cam learn a new offense just when we've finally got it working with Shula?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


  • PMH4OWPW7JD2TDGWZKTOYL2T3E.jpg

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Here is how I see it: Hendrickson is 4-5 years past the normal prime for an edge rusher.  However, the smart, elite edge rushers can play into their 30s.  So we would be taking a risk against the odds.  I see him as an elite, smart player,  but in 2025, he only played an average of 15 snaps per game.   We'd be paying him about 1.5 million per game, or $100,000 per snap at that rate. Hendrickson is 270, which makes him a guy who can rush inside or outside, hold the edge, and thus, be productive vs. the pass or run.   We have 2 guys (Scourton and Jones II) who do that pretty well.  Jones' salary is $10m.   I see our need as a pass-rushing specialist, hoping that Princely picks up that role rotationally at least, in 2026. Here is what AI says about age, and it does not lie: An NFL edge rusher's prime typically falls between ages 24 and 28, with peak production often seen around 27, though elite players maintain high production into their early 30s, with some legends excelling even later, demonstrating that while decline can start, great pass rushers defy age norms and can sustain elite play.  Peak Production Trends Early 20s (21-23): Players develop, with younger cohorts showing less immediate impact, but 23-year-olds often show significant pressure generation. Mid-to-Late 20s (24-28): This is the sweet spot, with the 27-year-old age group frequently leading the league in pressures and elite seasons occurring in this window. Early 30s (30+): While some decline begins, many top edge rushers remain highly effective, with stars like T.J. Watt and Myles Garrett demonstrating exceptional play well past 30, defying the average career trajectory.  Key Factors Physicality & Technique: Edge rushers need strength and speed, but mastery of pass-rush moves often develops later, allowing for sustained success. Individual Variation: Elite players like Bruce Smith and T.J. Watt show that exceptional talent and health can extend prime years significantly, with some even having more sacks after 30 than before. 
    • I just watched several nfl players break it down and this is NOT the case DJ was running a 20 yard out breaking crosser, he was supposed to flatten that route out.
    • Remember how we fired a coach for continuously taking us to the playoffs, but falling short of the Super Bowl?  No? Me either.
×
×
  • Create New...