Poll : Do you wish we still had 89?

[The Question]

 

At the risk of beating a dead horse, as of late with the Football Life special I've seen a lot of comments about Smith and whether or not we should have let him go. I know this might be a fodder-ish thread but I'm just interested in the numbers when there's a thread with an actual poll.

Take into consideration that it's now an actual quotable fact that he and Cam had some issues, but do you think those could have possibly been fleshed out with time and the maturation that Cam has underwent? Participate in the poll, post your thoughts. Or just tell me the threads trash. Either way.

Sent from my iPhone using CarolinaHuddle

 

[Saha]

89 was spectacular to watch on the field. His mastery was....masterful. Getting to see him on the field made the losses palatable. But football is the ultimate team sport. From everything I've seen reported it seems 89 could not put the team before the I. Thus he had to go by he wayside. I hated it then, I dislike it now. But ultimately we had to go with a more team first approach. Thus he's no longer with us.

 

thats how I see it anyways. Count it worth a hill of beans.

[t96]

I do wish that 89 could fit in with this team, yes. Unfortunately that's not a reality. Hope he signs the 1 day contract to retire a Panther officially, but I also kind of hope he postpones his retirement a little longer so he can get to #2 all time receiving yards behind Rice. Definitely still has it in him if he wanted to play through 39 or 40. Bet he retires after the year though as he's been saying.

[GoobyPls]

Yep, we haven't replaced what he brought to the team. Plus I would love to see how Kelvin and Smith complemented each other.

[B.BERSIN]

Yes, we need someone who has balls.


Sent from my iPhone using CarolinaHuddle

[The Question]

I voted for myself to stop posting.


Sent from my iPhone using CarolinaHuddle

[KillerKat]

Of all our other problems we have, this subject keeps popping up here. 

[PanthersGOATFan336]

How many different ways can one talk about the same subject

[The NFL Shield At Midfield]

28 minutes ago, PanthersGOATFan336 said:

How many different ways can one talk about the same subject

this gave me an idea for a new thread: "should we have kept josh norman?"

[juliosantos]

id love to have steve, gross , hardy,munnerlyn,mitchell, dangelo and mitchell back 

[Still Brooklyn]

Yes. He was entertaining ... the only reason I watch football. He'd still get yards (as seen in Baltimore). He was a Panther from day one and deserves to retire here. Yes, he and Cam would bicker over whose team it was, but that's not my concern, that's theirs. Dude is a HOF wr and was a blast to watch.