Keuchly [not yet, but soon] out of concussion protocol

[Snake]

This is a good sign but not a sure sign. 

[LinvilleGorge]

21 minutes ago, RoaringRiot said:

Because he Tweeted out "seem to suggest" and everyone takes it like he's saying "he's absolutely cleared"? Who's fault is that? 

If I was a professional reporter speculating on NFL concussion protocol, I'd at least understand the protocol first. 

 

[shulasmyhero]

9 minutes ago, LinvilleGorge said:

If I was a professional reporter speculating on NFL concussion protocol, I'd at least understand the protocol first. 

 

Yeah, Person doesn't report the news, he editorializes...

problem is he presents himself as a reporter.

[LinvilleGorge]

3 minutes ago, shulasmyhero said:

Yeah, Person doesn't report the news, he editorializes...

problem is he presents himself as a reporter.

Yep, he treats his job as a professional reporter like he's a poster on the Huddle. He's a professional. He should at least try to act like it. 

[RoaringRiot]

31 minutes ago, thomas96 said:

I don't care what people took it as or about the title of this thread or any of that. Anybody who can do 5 minutes of research about the concussion protocol would never even consider saying that Luke being at practice would suggest he's cleared. Lazy reporting and there are many more examples.

BREAKING: Reporters make mistakes, SEE: Adam Shefter about Luke being out of the protocol. 

I'm going to be over here writing a list of all the things I care more about than a reporter making an incorrect assumption so I'll be tied up for a few years. 

[RoaringRiot]

28 minutes ago, LinvilleGorge said:

If I was a professional reporter speculating on NFL concussion protocol, I'd at least understand the protocol first. 

 

I agree - he definitely should have. So? Why the fug are we giving this so much worry? 

[LinvilleGorge]

2 minutes ago, RoaringRiot said:

I agree - he definitely should have. So? Why the fug are we giving this so much worry? 

Better to bag on a reporter than dwell on how inept our coaching staff is. Feels less depressing. 

[RoaringRiot]

9 minutes ago, LinvilleGorge said:

Better to bag on a reporter than dwell on how inept our coaching staff is. Feels less depressing. 

I guess - feels like a tie to me. 

[Jon Snow]

4 minutes ago, RoaringRiot said:

I guess - feels like a tie to me. 

It's the Huddle way.

[xav8tor]

Last hour, Voth tweeted that Luke was "hitting sled, etc." at practice. So, there's your stage five proof. If Luke remains at baseline now and doesn't have any symptom recurrence, then, the final step is INC clearance, which could happen in time for the Tampa game. This appears to be a good thing, although it makes you wonder what the Monday appointment was for, unless the team doc wanted confirmation, second opinion, etc., or was greasing the wheels for the final eval by the INC.

[therealmjl]

1 minute ago, xav8tor said:

Last hour, Voth tweeted that Luke was "hitting sled, etc." at practice. So, there's your stage five proof. If Luke remains at baseline now and doesn't have any symptom recurrence, then, the final step is INC clearance, which could happen in time for the Tampa game. This appears to be a good thing, although it makes you wonder what the Monday appointment was for, unless the team doc wanted confirmation, second opinion, etc., or was greasing the wheels for the final eval by the INC.

Yeah I’m wondering what the point of his meeting yesteday was as well? Perhaps the team docs are playing it extra safe and waiting ?

[t96]

16 minutes ago, RoaringRiot said:

BREAKING: Reporters make mistakes, SEE: Adam Shefter about Luke being out of the protocol. 

I'm going to be over here writing a list of all the things I care more about than a reporter making an incorrect assumption so I'll be tied up for a few years. 

Everybody makes mistakes. Those who make them more than others are typically replaced by those who make less mistakes. As should happen at the Observer and with most of the Panthers media because they are terrible compared to other teams. Do I care? Not really, I've spent less than 2 hours total discussing our reporters on the Huddle over the past nearly 4 years of being on here, and outside of the very minimal discussion here I never give it a second thought. There are indeed a million things I care about more than this as well, however I'm capable of thinking about all that too and prioritizing that while still giving this subject a few minutes of my time. If you don't want to give it any of your time why do you bother responding to it here? 

[RoaringRiot]

9 minutes ago, thomas96 said:

Everybody makes mistakes. Those who make them more than others are typically replaced by those who make less mistakes. As should happen at the Observer and with most of the Panthers media because they are terrible compared to other teams. Do I care? Not really, I've spent less than 2 hours total discussing our reporters on the Huddle over the past nearly 4 years of being on here, and outside of the very minimal discussion here I never give it a second thought. There are indeed a million things I care about more than this as well, however I'm capable of thinking about all that too and prioritizing that while still giving this subject a few minutes of my time. If you don't want to give it any of your time why do you bother responding to it here? 

Talking about assumptions. What's that even based off of? 

You jumped all over Joe for saying Luke wasn't playing - oops. That's all I'm talking about. Stop wasting time worrying about our media. If you hate Person then read someone else. The solution is so easy that I feel dumb telling you. 

[*FreeFua*]

1 hour ago, RoaringRiot said:

Because he Tweeted out "seem to suggest" and everyone takes it like he's saying "he's absolutely cleared"? Who's fault is that? 

The average huddler can’t even read but leave it up to them to be the first to read inbetween the lines