THOUGHT ON MATT KALIL

[*FreeFua*]

25 minutes ago, pantherclaw said:

You obviously didn't pay attention to during the time Dave was here.

Enlighten us...

What did he do?

[*FreeFua*]

The amount of idiots that didn’t want Whitworth was mind blowing. Hope y’all happy with Kalil and that contract now

[SmokinwithWilly]

Let's be real. There wasn't much Dave could do with LT his first 2 years in FA thanks to the cap disaster Hurney left us in. Oher was serviceable in 15 even with the SB and there really wasn't any way to predict the concussion. 

I think Gman thought surgery and a new environment was going to fix Matt but it didn't. While he didn't do a lot to help it with Kalil this year, the previous 3 were out of his hands for the most part. 

[Saca312]

7 hours ago, raleigh-panther said:

but add to it the fact that Newton routinely lacks discipline in depth of his drop backs

[panther4life]

26 minutes ago, SmokinwithWilly said:

Let's be real. There wasn't much Dave could do with LT his first 2 years in FA thanks to the cap disaster Hurney left us in. Oher was serviceable in 15 even with the SB and there really wasn't any way to predict the concussion. 

I think Gman thought surgery and a new environment was going to fix Matt but it didn't. While he didn't do a lot to help it with Kalil this year, the previous 3 were out of his hands for the most part. 

If he didn’t waste money franchising Hardy he could have done something. He also didn’t have to restructure gross’ to expire a year early either. 

He also could have chose to draft one as well. Butler and Thompson were both luxury picks in the first round. 

He saved money by letting Norman walk after pulling the tag and then blew that whole wad on Kalil.

There were other instances where he wasted precious cap space too.

Paul Soliai for example. Had the 8th biggest cap hit in 2016. The same year he drafted Butler to ride the pine. Total wasted just shy of 5 million 

3.75 in cap hit in 16 and 1 million of dead in 17.

13.1 million in Hardy in 14

There’s more instances of course those just come to mind immediately and easily confirmed with a quick google search. 

Also the year before Gettleman got here the salary cap was 120 million.

By 2015 it jumped to $143 million 

and last year it was up to $167 million.

This year it will be 178 million. We are only rolling over 2.7 million from last year. 

Leaving us with 15 million to play with this year and important contracts expiring. If we didn’t dump Benjamin’s 8.5 million for next year we’d only have 6.5 to play with.

He was so over rated it’s not even funny. Giants fans better hope he learned from his mistakes just as we should hope Hurney learned from his.

 

[Mr. Scot]

9 hours ago, top dawg said:

I'm down for trying Moton, but I will defer to the judgement of  Matsko and Rivera. 

If we're talking offense, I might defer to Turner but not Rivera or Matsko.

[Mr. Scot]

6 hours ago, theballboy said:

Say that to you. After Gross retired, Dave brought in Bell

Did he, now?

[TheRed]

7 hours ago, pantherclaw said:

You obviously didn't pay attention to during the time Dave was here.

Oh, did ol' Dave find us a franchise left tackle? I wasn't aware. Last I checked we backed up a brinks truck to Matt Kalil who has been anything but good.

[Mr. Scot]

2 minutes ago, theballboy said:

What

Should I bother explaining?

 

 

Nah.

[Daddy_Uncle]

Norv is a very strong offensive mind. He knows where is weaknesses are and how to fix them. If that means putting an extra blocking TE by Kalil then he'll do it. I'm hoping he locates and fix weaknesses quickly

[Mr. Scot]

4 minutes ago, theballboy said:

When you are signing a guy like Kalil who you know that he needs a new scenary, you dont give him a 5yr/55mil. You give him a 1-2 yr prove it deal. Like really, what’s the sole purpose of giving Kalil that much money? Based on what? His rookie year? or bc Ryan Kalil his brother was vouching for him?

Kalil's deal has an out after two years.

[panther4life]

5 minutes ago, Mr. Scot said:

Kalil's deal has an out after two years.

Still will cost us $26 million for 2 years of service. It’s a bad deal no matter how you shake a stick at it.

[Mr. Scot]

1 minute ago, panther4life said:

Still will cost us $26 million for 2 years of service. It’s a bad deal no matter how you shake a stick at it.

That depends a lot on what he does next year.

[CPF4LIFE]

Lmaooo....kalil not doing a damn thing next year. Speed bump mcgee vol. 2

I really wish this coaching staff would have the balls to play the best players on the roster. Forget status, contracts, experience, etc.

It irritates the hell out of me. I wanna see what we have in moton next year, im not trying to wait till he is in year 3 of his deal and  finally getting significant playing time.