Rosinski brings out the tinfoil hat

[Mr. Scot]

Gotta assume "Marty" is referring to Marty Hurney.

Oliver Luck has directly denied that Andrew staying in school had anything to do with the Panthers, but even if that's true it doesn't negate the possibility that Archie Manning might have said something to him.

[vorbis]

if true then Richardson did the franchise a big favor by accident

[Nails]

1 minute ago, vorbis said:

if true then Richardson did the franchise a big favor by accident

Yuge

[Cary Kollins]

If that’s the case thank god for pie charts

[ColumbusCounty]

Pie chart or not..lol I'm forever greatful for whomever the party was that convinced this dude to stay another year.

[Mr. Scot]

I remember somebody on here (probably our phony retired coach) trying to argue that nobody was offended by Richardson saying that stuff.

T'would seem otherwise.

[tondi]

Some people are visual learners. Maybe neckbeard isnt one of them. 

[Moo Daeng]

That incident happened a month after Luck decided to stay.

Nice try Bill

http://www.espn.com/college-football/news/story?id=5995754

https://profootballtalk.nbcsports.com/2011/02/13/jay-feely-jerry-richardson-insults-intelligence-of-players/

[4Corners]

55 minutes ago, Mr. Scot said:

Gotta assume "Marty" is referring to Marty Hurney.

Oliver Luck has directly denied that Andrew staying in school had anything to do with the Panthers, but even if that's true it doesn't negate the possibility that Archie Manning might have said something to him.

Cam > Luck 

 

[Moo Daeng]

Should have been obvious there were no league negotiations going on during the season. Luck made his decision early January 

[Mr. Scot]

6 minutes ago, Moo Daeng said:

That incident happened a month after Luck decided to stay.

Nice try Bill

http://www.espn.com/college-football/news/story?id=5995754

https://profootballtalk.nbcsports.com/2011/02/13/jay-feely-jerry-richardson-insults-intelligence-of-players/

Yep. Timeline is off.

So then the question becomes whether Rosinski actually got this story from Hurney or just made it up.

[R2-D2]

And now Andrew luck is dead. 

Jokes on you bitch

[Moo Daeng]

I'm sure he made it up. This subject comes up from time to time. Fact do matter

[Mr. Scot]

Looked back a little further.  Turns out there were two pie chart stories.

Richardson's "uncomfortable" press conference occurred on January 4th, 2011.  During that infamous presser, he pulled out a pie chart which was supposed to show that the NFL wasn't making as much money as was claimed.  This occurred three days before Luck's announcement on January 7th.  The incident where Richardson asked Drew Brees and Peyton Manning whether they knew how to read a pie chart occurred a month later on February 5th during an NFL/NFLPA negotiating session.

Now that said, Rosinski's story pretty clearly seems to be referencing the second incident, because why would Brees or Manning have cared about the first? It didn't involve either of them.

Is it possible Rozinski is just confusing the story (or that Hurney was, depending on who the ultimate source actually is)?  Perhaps what Archie Manning actually said was "good thing your kid stayed in school" or something of that sort.

Or perhaps nothing at all.  Who can say?

Regardless, without some clarification/revision, the story doesn't sound especially credible at this point.