Which Panther was the GOAT?

[Cdw]

This is a tough one, a good argument could be made for any of them.  I'll go with Cam because he played the most important position and at times carried the team to victory like no one other player could.   

[Brooklyn 3.0]

4 hours ago, rodeo said:

NFL career/season records held by Steve Smith: 0

NFL career/season records held by Cam Newton: 12

I stand by my statement. There are 20 QBs better than Cam. Maybe more.

[Doyle]

4 hours ago, rodeo said:

NFL career/season records held by Steve Smith: 0

NFL career/season records held by Cam Newton: 12

Steve Smith broken noses: 2

Cam Newton: 0

Smitty or go fug yourself   

 

[arbnranger]

On 3/27/2020 at 9:05 AM, GoobyPls said:

Peppers will be the only one in that group to be first ballot.

 

I think Smith was better at his position then the other 3 were at theirs, problem is Smith played a position that’s more depended on others. If Smith played on a pass first team with a good QB theirs no doubt in my mind he’s second to Jerry Rice in yards.

Disagree. 
Luke will be I believe and fairly certain about it.   

[arbnranger]

On 3/27/2020 at 9:45 AM, MHS831 said:

Could have, but that does not disqualify you from being a great player.  Brady could have played better a few years back and the Pats lost. 

Agree ...but kicker never gets the designation greatest player on any team .. ever. 
no reason to put him in the mix. 
 

He also lost us the Super Bowl 

[GoobyPls]

2 hours ago, arbnranger said:

Disagree. 
Luke will be I believe and fairly certain about it.   

Retired to early imo

 

 

[onmyown]

3 hours ago, arbnranger said:

Disagree. 
Luke will be I believe and fairly certain about it.   

Peppers will be more unanimous.

He is without a doubt the best player ever to play here fo most his career.

And to think he was just a physical freak but he didn’t have a love/passion for the game. Imagine how good he’d be with a Reggie white/Keuchly/ray Lewis type fire? 

[kungfoodude]

23 minutes ago, onmyown said:

Peppers will be more unanimous.

He is without a doubt the best player ever to play here fo most his career.

And to think he was just a physical freak but he didn’t have a love/passion for the game. Imagine how good he’d be with a Reggie white/Keuchly/ray Lewis type fire? 

If he had that kind of passion for the game, he may well have proved to be the greatest player to ever play in the NFL.

[panthers55]

If you are counting just how a player did as a Panther then Smith, Cam, and Luke were all the greatest at their position. But if you are talking about the Panther player who had the greatest career it would be Peppers who is already considered a lock as a first ballot HOFer.  He played for the Panthers, Bears, Packers and the Panthers again. Started and finished his illustrious career as a Panther. 

Popularity wise he was too much of an introvert at least the first time around. Didn't come across well on the media.