Brady vs Chudzinski

[Moo Daeng]

Hard to say. We already know Chud didn't have a particularly successful go in the NFL. Brady still might.

Chud had a better roster ti work with considering the pretty good OL, TEs, running backs, Smith, and  fearless Gung ho fresh Newton

[Beerfacedlegend]

6 hours ago, WarHeel said:

Sanjay?

I was thinking about that tight end loving guy the other day , to be honest he was right he wanted to draft nick chubb and Troy fumagali

[MechaZain]

Brady > Chud. Imagine Brady with rookie Cam.

[JawnyBlaze]

Brady, easily. Chud was good, I liked him, but he went off the deep end in year two. I thought Brady’s play designs were better though, and haven’t seen whether he’d fall off the deep end in year two yet. 

[BrianS]

Brady 100%.

While the two TE concepts are interesting, the ability to scheme up plays that made Curtis Samuel look like the guy we always hoped he would be showed me far more innovation.  I would love to see Brady with a real QB, a healthy CMC and the DJ / Robby combo out wide.

[Davidson Deac II]

Chud had a better qb to work with, Brady has a more talented offense overall.  But they both had the same problem.  Their offenses tended to struggle in the 4th qtr.  

[Mr. Scot]

17 hours ago, Varking said:

Brady

With nobody of note at QB or tight end and missing his star running back all year he developed this team to get four dudes to cross 1k yards and had us in most games. Those close games and the red zone struggles tend to not carry over from year to year. The scoring will come. 

I'd probably have taken Brady too.