Who would you rather have? Moore or Palmer?

[mattmoorefan]

Who is the better qb? Just wanted to see what people think. I say Palmer.

[Guild]

I'd rather just see what Moore brings to the table in the off and preseason.

That is I'd rather do that then entertain the notion of the guy who just lost to the Jets joining our team when there is about a -50% chance of it ever happening.

[mattmoorefan]

I'd rather just see what Moore brings to the table in the off and preseason.

I think Moore is going to be really special. I have liked him since college and always new he would turn out good but the only reason I say Palmer is because of experience.

[PhillyB]

palmer, if we were thinking immediately... but i'm thinking moore will continue playing at a high level for a long time, so long-term, i'd go with moore, simply because he's younger.

[holderoftruth]

I'm just not a big fan of Jordan Palmer, so i'll go with Moore.

[Brooklyn Bully]

Palmer is better right now, and ultimately I think he will end up better than Moore. That's not a knock on Moore at all. Palmer is an elite QB. He's just had some injuries and shoddy O-Lines in front of him thus far.

[Wither]

Moore. Do not bring in any FA quarterbacks as the ones who will be available are the ones who faltered and fell with their last team. As for the draft, bring in a QB to compete with Moore (but most likely Moore will win) and then keep the dude as a backup or future QB.

[CatMan72]

At this point Palmer, he's a proven commodity.

[mattmoorefan]

I'm just not a big fan of Jordan Palmer, so i'll go with Moore.

not jordan, carson

[PantherDude]

Palmer, no question. While Moore will get better, I doubt he will ever be good as Palmer is. Palmer is one of the top 10 QB in the NFL right now & I know Moore will never reach that status.

[falconlynx]

Palmer has not seemed the same to me since the knee injury.

I really like Moore, but I expect Jake to beat him out for at least one more year. I think Jake is going to have a strong season next year.

Never count someone that competitive out, even if he did throw 18 picks and had a horrid season.

[panthers55]

Pretty random thread. These guys are not close to each other in terms of experience, or anything else. Moore has started a total of 8 games, Palmer is a 6 year vet who has started 81. Palmer is 30 and actually in the prime of his career while Moore is 25 years and just beginning his career. One is a number 1 pick, the other a UDFA. One is a 2 time probowler, the other hasn't completed one season.

[Jangler]

Palmer looked great in the last two game against the Jets, so yeah lets bring in Jake 2.0...

[Bama Panther]

The prevailing view up here in the Dayton/Cincinnati area is that Palmer has not fully recovered from the knee injury. The talk is that he favors the leg and doesn't plant properly, which has lead to many poor passing efforts this season. That includes Saturday's game.